The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 6 · December 1903
362printed page
scan 31 of 63

thing to foresee that with a settlement inEast Africa we shall have a body of Jews inthat Continent in touch with their motherland, and that, hence, the settlement will beof immense importance to us when we get toPalestine.

Let us ask ourselves, What will those who come after us say of us if for mere sentimental reasons we do not accept this offer? They will say, "Our forefathers were offered by the British Government the establishment of what could have been a magnificent colony and they foolishly and stupidly refused it." I know it is looking far ahead, but for my part I will not have it upon my conscience that I did otherwise than assist in taking advantage for our future State of the brilliant chance that has been opened for us. Now, we have heard to-night something as to the necessity for organization and discipline. And I would ask further, is all the influence of our great leader to count for naught? Some people speak as if he had done nothing to justify the position of Zionism in the world, and as if his views on this scheme were to be a negligible quantity. Personally, I think that his opinion should go for more than that of very many of those who oppose him, and as he has decided, after hearing everything that can be said against the scheme, surely our business is, at least, to support him in his work. If he is going to be our leader, he must lead us and we must follow.

I am anxious not to bind myself to any opinion as to the practicability or the desirability of East Africa for the purposes of a Jewish settlement till the Commission reports, but here is an offer made by the British Government generously and nobly. I ask you, let us receive it in the spirit in which I believe it was made. It was given to us in no grudging spirit. If we find it feasible and practical let us accept it. After all, we Jews owe an immense debt of gratitude to this great country and to its Government, and if we can plan in British East Africa a successful Jewish colony we ought to be proud to be the means of adding another jewel to the British Crown

I hope that those who oppose this proposal will earnestly reconsider what they have said and that they will find themselves in a position to join hands with and assist us. They cannot at least be deaf to the cries of their

brethren. It is because I have faith in this scheme and because I believe that if we found this settlement our people will establish a colony which will be inestimably valuable to Jewry and to the world that I support it.

That scheme which goes by Rev. I. Harris, the name of Zionism may or M.A., London may not be practicable in the extreme form which contemplates the rehabilitation of Jewish nationality. It may not even be desirable in that form. But the heroic efforts of Dr. Herzl to find "a legally-safeguarded home" for persecuted Jews have surely deserved more sympathetic consideration than has been accorded them. Speaking as one who is entirely unconnected with the Zionist Movement, and therefore in no spirit of partisanship, it seems to me that the acquisition of autonomous Jewish settlements, whether in Palestine or in East Africa is a measure which might also, in its way, help to ameliorate the lot of the oppressed; that though it could not solve the Jewish Question, it might contribute something toward its solution.

It is surely not a far-fetched supposition that there is a large section of Jews for whom ordinary colonizing and emigration schemes have no attraction, but who would eagerly become cultivators of the soil if they were settled in a land which they could call their own. A section who argue somewhat in this way: "If we must emigrate let it be to a country in which we shall not be regarded as alien intruders; if we must change our fatherland, let us exchange it for the land of our fathers—the land which has been the center of Israel's hopes ever since Israel became a people; or, if this be not possible, for a land in which we shall be in no danger of creating about ourselves a hostile environment. We look round, and we see a mighty wave of Protectionism sweeping over the world, so that there is scarcely a country in which we should be welcome to settle. Among the freest nations of the earth our presence has created grave problems. Why intensify those problems, when there is at least one territory which a great and enlightened Government has offered us as our own?" That is how we may imagine many members of the persecuted communities of