British East Africa and Zionism
THERE are now great, real and live issues before the Jewish people. Every Zionist must have an opinion on the relationship of Zionism to the offer of the British Government to permit of the formation of a Jewish national settlement in British East Africa. Every Jew, too, whatever his station, should form his opinion on a question that, one way or the other, will affect the future of the Jewish people.
We shall, therefore, give every possible space in forthcoming issues of THE MACCABÆAN to the publication of opinions on this question. We invite every Zionist to write us his or her opinion, and we ask them to urge their friends, too, to send us opinions on this matter.
Opinions, which should be expressed in not more than one hundred and fifty words, can be sent in English, Yiddish, Hebrew or German (Latin character); but must be legibly written on one side of the paper only, and must be authenticated with the name and address of the writer, and Zionist organization, if any. Envelopes should be clearly marked "Opinion," and addressed to the Editor of THE MACCABÆAN, 320 Broadway, New York.
Since we first issued this offer, we have collected the following opinions:
Rev. Dr. M. Gaster It scarcely requires a long explanation that “New Zionism,” the word used by Mr. Zang-
will in his apology for the late turn in the policy of the Zionists, has absolutely nothing in common with Zionism proper, unless one means to confuse the adherents of the new movement, who happen to be Zionists, with the object of their activity. It is an euphemism for the somersault performed at Basle; the fig-leaf to cover the East African nakedness. If the question of East Africa had not provoked such passionate outbursts and discussions in the Zionist Congress, and if the advocates of this new policy had not been leaders of the Zionist movement no man would have dreamed of pronouncing the two terms, Zion and East Africa, in one breath. Without any preparation having been made, without any steps having been taken to prepare the spirits, a bomb was thrown into the Congress and the delegates, who had not the remotest idea of the scheme and were not even in a position to grasp adequately the tremendous import of the proposition, were induced to vote for
it, affected by the sudden explosion and acting under influences which need not be dilated upon.
But whatever the scheme may have in store for us, and I will try and sketch later on some of the consequences, though I should not like to play the prophet before the time, it is our peremptory duty to fix again the standpoint from which the delegates in Basle have deviated and which alone can be considered as Zionistic. All the rest, whatever name it may bear, is Pseudo-Zionism, self deception, a snare and a delusion.
The Zionist Question and the Jewish Question are not identical; they do not represent the same ideas and the same conceptions, and they cannot be exchanged for each other. The one is connected exclusively with the Jewish misery (Judennot), whereas the other, the former, is absolutely independent of it.
The Jewish Question deals only with the fact that the Jews do not yet possess in some countries of Europe full political and social equality and in others they are somewhat forcibly deprived of the enjoyment of those