tempt there is being made to educate the Jewish youth Jewishly is unsystematic, or without intelligent tendency. (The exceptions to this broad statement are so notable as to require no mention.) Jewish education in this country contents itself with either teaching the reading of Hebrew in the prayer-book and in the Bible, or a few of the tenets of the religion. But, so far it has not tended, nor does it promise to tend to the development, in the minds of the Jewish youth, of a Jewish consciousness, either religious or national.
Without the slightest desire to criticize the methods in vogue, in either the private schools (Chedarim) or public schools (Talmud Torahs, religious classes, etc.) it must be said that even if the pedagogic methods were perfect, there is very little to attract the Jewish youth of America, and particularly the growing boys, to these public or private schools. At its very best, the Jewish education of the Jewish youth, in this country, inflicts a considerable amount of hardship upon the youth. Attendance at any of these schools means the deprivation of the right of the boy (we are dealing here with the boy exclusively) to have a certain part of the day for recreation. That this right is inherent—that the recognition of this inherent right is essential in any successful educational curriculum is too well established to permit of any discussion. How much more important therefore is the recognition of the right of the boy by any organization desirous that the Jewish youth of America shall be induced (not cajoled) into accepting Jewish education? Even more important is the recognition of this right, when we have before us the unalterable fact that Jewish education for the youth of this country must be given, and partaken of, after the closing of the sessions of the general schools, when the youthful mind has already become wearied with the work in these schools, and the youthful body craves the stimulus of healthy, normal, youthful exercise.
Very naturally, education (even with the best pedagogic methods) becomes very difficult under such circumstances. Add to the rebellious attitude of the boy's mind, the unwholesome, uncheerful, physical environment in which such education is most generally attempted and the lack of discipline which is
prevalent (except in the notable exceptions already referred to) and the obvious consequence must be, and is, failure! Only those who are gifted with a natural inclination, or better said, with a ravenous appetite for knowledge can rise superior to these unpromising conditions, and derive benefit from the attempt at Jewish education. The rest, the boys of average temperament, attend these schools only so long as they are in fear of parental discipline, and this we are aware, is far too lax in this country, and especially so in those homes where the paramount problem is that of existence.
All of this augurs ill for the future of Judaism in this country.. We are not concerned, nor need we be, with the future of the Jew asa citizen of this country, as a valuable member of society. The Jew will take his proper place in the ranks of American citizenship, without the aid of any other agencies than those which mold the rest of America’s heterogenous masses into one harmonious American body. But, this applies only to the material phase. For the Jew, however, there is the spiritual phase, without the proper development of which, the Jew cannot take his rightful place in the citizenship of the world. For others, the ordinary school methods may suffice, but, for centuries, the Jew has had religion as the basis of his education—his spiritual foundation. This he is losing in this country. American conditions, which we need not recount here, are taking it from him. This we must restore. We must educate the Jew as a Jew. Failure to do this, threatens our future in this country with an undeveloped Jewish consciousness. It means ignorance of the highest meaning of Judaism, the chief lessons of Jewish history, a lack of harmony between children and parents, And among the more spiritually inclined, a susceptibility to influences, which however good, are non-Jewish, if not anti-Jewish. In fine, an unfitness to receive and assume the responsibilities of Israel’s heritage.
These are not discoveries. Nothing novel is stated here. We have endeavored to summarize, as briefly as the subject will permit, conditions to which many call attention, and consequences that cause many to cry out warnings against.
But, though many have spoken, none has
