The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 5 · November 1903
311printed page
scan 34 of 56

The Maccabæan

EDITORIAL PAGES

J. DE HAAS, EDITOR

HERALDING THE DAWN

THE Jewish situation is undergoing a significant change—a change better realized at this juncture in Europe than here in the United States. “Zionism is,” Mr. Cyrus L. Sulzberger’s way of stating our case to the unrealizing communities on this side of the Atlantic, has been understood in a most acute sense in Europe. The British offer to the Sixth Congress has aroused interest in Russia in a fashion that overshadows even the accounts of delegates being punished for their temerity in attending the Congress. Mr. Lucien Wolf by his bitter attack on this same project has aroused the interest of the Anglo-Jewish community, and it is fast rallying to the cause. The Jewish Chronicle, our erstwhile foremost opponent, has frankly changed its position and claims, in addition, that Dr. Adler, the Chief Rabbi, stands with us at least as far as the East African project is concerned, and on the day of Atonement the minister of the Reform Synagogue, the Rev. Isidor Harris, and the minister of the Hampstead Synagogue, the Rev. A. A. Green, once before a supporter, paid the Zionists that tribute which tells us that we are not laboring in vain in the effort to unite our people around the banner of their ancient ideals. The European press is seething with the issue not merely of East Africa, but of Jewish life as a whole. From St. Petersburg to London the reality of the Jewish problem is apparent in newspaper, in review, and the solution of difficulties is admittedly not sophism. Nor is this all. The newspapers are publishing messages which even though they be not true are full of interest. Thus we learn from those whose business it is to indulge in “intelligent anticipation of events,” that the French Government is about to offer Madagascar to the Zionists on terms similar to those propounded by the British Government in relation to East Africa; that the Russian Government is making similar offers in respect to a large tract

of territory in Manchuria; and lastly that the Sultan of Turkey has sent for Dr. Herzl and has closed negotiations by which the Zionists take over tracts of land on both sides of the Jordan!

In May last, when the Kishineff massacre occurred, Jewry was in despair. Where should we turn? What should be done? Only the fanatic Zionists were comparatively tranquil and hopeful. Now the cable in its cool, deliberate way tells us there are four practical alternatives: East Africa, Madagascar, Manchuria and Zion. The messages are “cool and deliberate” because, notwithstanding a protest meeting in Nairobia, the great English world has not said nay to its Government; because the French have not shouted “Jueverie” at the suggestion of Madagascar; because no one has exclaimed “impossible” concerning Manchuria, and the long promised fanatic outbreak—a bugbear to so many Jews—has not followed the announcement that the Sultan has ceded the Jordanic territory. Presuming even that these three newspaper reports are mere trial balloons, attempts of different governments at testing the public temper, the change is clear enough in two particulars. It is evident from these messages that European writers or statesmen hold that a deal with the Jews is feasible, because the Zionists are possible negociants; further, that the Zionist agitation is so well in accord with the great public mind that it is prepared to acquiesce in any national Jewish settlement from Africa to Zion itself. If the “ne’er consenting” consent, we have no reason for looking at the back of the motive.

The needs of our people on the one hand, and our ideals on the other, enable us to overcome any sense of injury to our amour propre which this readiness to be rid of us in Eastern Europe at least suggests. Nor is the “get rid of” the strongest reason for the approval we are winning from Western civilization. The rapidity with which Biblical warrant, otherwise interpretation of prophetic texts, has been found for the East African scheme shows plainly that however humdrum we regard ourselves, and however humane our efforts, the Christian religious conscience looks forward to our work with great expectancy, and continues to take its stand upon the logic of its teaching that humanity must gain through Israel “coming to its own again.”