The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 5 · November 1903
304printed page
scan 27 of 56
Facsimile · scan 27 of 56
Scan of p. 304
Text · transcribed from the scan

have been said? Would we have not been held to be mere dreamers and star-gazers, for here we have something palpable before us, something that might have brought salvation to numbers of our downtrodden people, and we spurned it? Truly we would have shown ourselves as utterly unpractical. . . . But if the report of the expedition is unfavorable, even then our gain will have been great, because the fact of the recognition of our cause by so great a Power as England will still remain a fact. If, on the other hand, the report prove satisfactory, besides affording help to our poverty-stricken wanderers and material benefit to the body corporate of Israel, it will permit of the national life being lived, and so result in direct help toward our ultimate goal—the Zionist ideal. We should then be able to treat for our country on quite a different footing, without utilizing hazardous expedients, forced upon us by the immediate necessity. . . . There are men among us now, true Zionists, who are not averse to the idea of colonization in general—and surely the proposed African scheme is in no wise inferior to such plans.”

To the query whether the African question did not threaten the party with division and

the organization with disaster, Dr. Herzl replied: “I have not thought about the cleavage that may result. I have devoted myself to the African proposal, solely because it appeals to my inmost convictions, and had the majority been against me, including my dearest colleagues, it would not have made me swerve from my position. . . . But you see the majority supported me, and I am not without hope that the vast mass of Jewry will confirm what the Congress has decided upon.” . . . I then told Dr. Herzl that the Sixth Congress impressed me with the idea that he had determined to stand, not merely at the head of the Zionist movement, but of Jewry as a whole, and that he wished the African proposition to be not a Zionist question merely, but a Jewish question. At this the leader’s eyes shot fire, and then came the curt answer: “You will see that you are deeply mistaken. The next Congress will be strictly Zionist, and only in the ranks of the Zionists shall we work for the African project, if it is to be, and the majority of Zionists are for it. . . . My striving for Zion will now be greater and more powerful, for now new forces and new conditions are ranging themselves on our side. . . .”