of Herzl, Nordau, Zangwill and others compelled serious thought and careful weighing of the matter. The entire thing, except the implied and very gratifying recognition of our cause by a world power, is, I think, an unfortunate wrinkle in the fair complexion of Zionism, and ought to be declined with thanks and kept out of the programme.
Albert M. Friedenberg East Africa by all means. The economic basis of Zionism presupposes that Zionism has for its aim primarily the alleviation of anomalous and untoward Jewish conditions in countries of persecution. East Africa is the fruition of Zionist endeavor, so far at least as amelioration is concerned. It is a preparation ground, too, for if Zion has such potent charm for the Jew as to cause his right hand to lose its cunning should he ever forget Zion, then the Jew in East Africa may continue to fight and dream for Zion. Against East Africa there is but this: it is not Zion. Personally I admire the Russian Congress delegates for acting as they did, for it shows that Zion is a living force to them still. But cannot the power of imagination recreate anywhere in the world, even in East Africa, Zion? I hope one day to be more explicit on this point. East Africa can never be old Zion, but a new Zion it can and will surely be, if the Jews accept the British offer.
A Friendly Gentile If the country is healthy, and has a good port; accept it!
The acceptance will show to the whole civilized world that you are recognized by the British Government as a political body, representing your people, wherever scattered—a matter of great importance just now; while many of those who would go to Mombasa as a refuge, flying from ill treatment or weary of abuse, would lay hold permanently and develop for England the trade of the back country, as none of her very own sons has yet done; those who all the time pine for the "old land" will be better off to go to it, when it is "renewed," than they would have been had they remained to be harried in Roumania or Russia.
And renewed it will be, before our grandchildren are old men; for, when the Great Bear makes his final grab, and Father John, Uncle Sam and others step in and shout
"NO!—the Bosphorus and Dardanelles must be neutralized," and call on the Rothschilds to undertake the job, these will have to refuse to send cadets to Byzantium with that object in view, unless the civilized world gives you, and the Montefiores and others who feel with you, a God-speed-you on your way to the Land of your Fathers.
The generous and highRev. Dr. Bernard minded offer of the British Drachman Government to the Jewish people, through Dr. Theodor Herzl and the Zionist Congress, to cede an extensive tract of land in the East African Protectorate for the establishment of a Jewish autonomous state under British suzerainty, is one of great and epoch-making importance. As such it is entitled to the most earnest and careful consideration on the part of all elements of the Jewish people, not only of those who have hitherto warmly advocated the Zionistic scheme, but, as well, of those who have opposed it, or been indifferent thereto. That it is imperatively necessary that some radical steps be taken to relieve the intense misery of the millions of persecuted brethren in Eastern Europe, and to prevent the bulk of the Hebrew race from sinking into a condition of abject wretchedness and degradation, all thoughtful observers are agreed. That the proposal does not completely satisfy the hopes and aspirations of Jewish souls, which have always, since the beginning of the dispersion, been filled with the longing to see the nation re-established in its historic home, is equally true and that, therefore, there is warm and emphatic opposition to it on the part of many to whom the Zionistic ideal is precious, and who fear that other proposals may injure or destroy it, is entirely natural and intelligible. The writer holds that these fears are groundless, that the establishment of an autonomous Jewish state outside of Palestine is not in contradiction to the Zionistic ideal and will not destroy or diminish, but, on the contrary, will greatly strengthen interest in the movement and that true consideration for the future of the Jewish people imperatively demands that we at once accept and utilize to the utmost possible extent the splendid offer of the British Government. True love for Zion does not mean that Jews may only dwell in the land which was actually occupied by their ancestors in