The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
261printed page
scan 62 of 80

Herzl proved himself a master, it was in the handling of the official issue. There are Zionistswho are socialists, Zionists who never are politicians when they can demonstrate their owniconoclasms. The one hundred and twenty of the Mizrachi who are political and orthodox, the“left” party which is sitting on the right, etc., Kishineff, El-Arisch, the English offer, the undertaking of the Russian Government, tinder enough, which is ignited would put all the heatherin_flame. But the personality of the leader overcame it all. Those of us who fain would haveburned one-half of these matters in a lumber room of time, admitted that he was cleverer thanus all. But the Congress did not really comprehend the budget of information conveyed in apolitical address which will rank among the historic documents of this age; and so, whilst theycheer and cheer to the echo, we are anxious to get away to the conference rooms in which wecan discuss all these affairs. Every landsmanchaft began to meet at once and a buzz of excitement filled the building from end to end.

The afternoon sitting was long. Oscar Marmorek, who could tell a great deal about camel riding in El Arish, read the report of the Actions Comité. It covered both the story of the growing misery of Israel and the phenomenal development of our movement. But two-thirds of us, or perhaps nine-tenths, forgot all about it till we saw it again on paper, for the longest innings was given to Davis Trietsch, who was once howled down for his Cyprus plans, and now indulged in an all-round criticism of the leader and in the almost intolerable assumption that if the Congress had half the confidence in him that it has in Herzl he would do twice as much. To speak by the book, Trietsch, as he stood there, with his white face and the smiles of his fiancée directed toward him, presented a sometimes pitiable sight, and never even looked half a Herzl. But we took it in good humor, for, after all, the African scheme was at the back of us.

Dr. Herzl, however, took it with a different grace. He sat below the tribune, took copious notes with his blue pencil, and then went in for the wholesale demolition of Trietsch's proprietary claims in El Arish, and his pottering and planting out schemes of settlement. The personal battle was dramatic, especially when Dr. Herzl calmly rendered an affidavit and brought the witnesses into the Congress. The building seethed with fire and fury. The notetakers of personal impressions had a splendid opportunity, and the reporters of the anti-Zionist papers rushed some brilliant messages.

By way of contrast, in the room at the back of the platform. the whole machinery of the movement was being turned quietly and unostentatiously by a little committee, the members of which only now and then stole out to hear such sarcasms as that Trietsch was a Baron Hirsch without millions. The irrepressible Trietsch hurled back, “You're another.”

When we got back to the calm of our hotel, it was not a little interesting to hear people asking why they had not been Zionists before, but there were hundreds such round about upon whom a great mass of intellectual earnestness and intelligent enthusiasm worked like the electric current. The vast mass of the delegates went to chew the cud of the African project. It seemed indigestible, and when the Basle market resumed in the morning there were some who were probably still at it.

August 24.

The forenoon was Nordau's to-day. The threat of a hoot at the opening session when Nordau was elected was never realized. But the Cultur party had evidently turned tail, and when the redoubtable fighter again got behind the green baize, he turned to all sides of the building, calmly challenging dissent. It never came. There will be differences of opinion as to which of the Nordau orations are the best. This time he spoke with really no preparation. Four times he paused to reflect on the notes written on his visiting card and held the Congress spellbound. It was anti-Zion that he challenged on the political side, and a kind of thunder rolled through the Congress building when he spoke of the impregnable granite character of the Basle programme, and yet, with a dexterous twist, coined his "night refuge" in East Africa.

Then began the real debate. The house was full. Speaker after speaker rolled off his views on this African scheme. But we got back to the main report again with the big white