The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
250printed page
scan 51 of 80
Facsimile · scan 51 of 80
Scan of p. 250
Text · transcribed from the scan

MR. LEOPOLD J. GREENBERG.

am not asking you to have any special confidence in me. But you owe a proof of your confidence to your leader. You owe him the means of action for which he asks you, and by giving it him you will in no way prejudice any future decisions.

The reason is: it is a courtesy we owe England. You do not, all of you, at present fully appreciate the fact that one of the great Powers of the world should commence negotiations with the Jewish people and makes a proposal which implies practically no service to be rendered in return by us. They are willing to give. This is such a fair promise that my political instinct almost tells that it is too good to be true. Will you not do a small act of courtesy, to show your appreciation of the great courtesy shown you? Will you decline a proposal of such a nature, without even thinking it worthy of being considered? The speaker who addressed you before me said, "Our trusty Dr. Herzl will not fail to arrange matters!" Very well, let us begin by breaking the china; Herzl will not fail to put it together again. Consider well what you do if you refuse to the leader

whom you profess to trust the means of replying with the most ordinary courtesy to the proposal made by the British Government. Consider the responsibility which you take upon yourselves if you declare that there shall be no means of political education for the Jewish people. You can now safely constitute the committee and say, "Whatever the committee may decide, whatever a subsequent Congress may decide, whatever we do outside Palestine can only be meant and understood as a preparation for Palestine."

Mr. L. J. Greenberg, whose speech was translated into German by Dr. Nordau, said that having been intrusted by Dr. Herzl to carry on the negotiations with the British Government, he would like to express his personal views on the subject, but he would say that they were not in the least bound to accept the offer of the English Government, an offer which was only due to the wish to see the position of the Jewish race improved. The scheme was first broached to Dr. Herzl by Mr. Chamberlain, but so long as the El Arish question was still open, Dr. Herzl did not consider East Africa. When the El Arish project was abandoned, Mr. Chamberlain again kindly placed himself in communication with Dr. Herzl regarding the East African settlement. The exact territory has not yet been decided. The region which Mr. Chamberlain said would suit the colony lay between Nairobi and Mau escarpment. It was described as a highland, and its climate like that in the southern part of England. The land between Nairobi and Mau escarpment was on the railway from Mombasa to Port Florence. Should the concession be made, the British Government would grant a piece of land comprising 200 to 300 English miles. Mr. Greenberg then read the following letter:

FOREIGN OFFICE, August 14, 1903.

SIR: Mr. Chamberlain communicated to the Marquis of Lansdowne the letter which you addressed to him on the 13th ult., containing the form of an agreement which Dr. Herzl proposes should be entered into between His Majesty's Government and the Jewish Colonial Trust, Ltd., for the establishment of a Jewish settlement in East Africa. His lordship has also had under his consideration