The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
249printed page
scan 50 of 80
October, 1903.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
240

cient?” He also has failed to see the difference. Jews were sent to Argentina and Canada to cease to be Jews, to be assimilated into non-Jewish surroundings, and to remain the disinherited minority which they had been in the countries they had left. We do not propose—how could you fail to see it?—to send Jews anywhere, to Argentina or Canada or some other country, but to a country where they shall be Jews, where they shall live their National life, where they will be brought up to be Jewish citizens and where their children will grow up in Jewish traditions. Do you really think that there is no difference? Dr. Levin made another weighty objection, and I remind you that as soon as he said the phrase I am going to quote there was thunderous assent in the hall. He said, “What do we want with East Africa? We have Erez Israel.” I am glad to hear this. Please, give it to us if you have it. (Cheers.)

I wish to make the following statement to avoid all possibility of error, I personally can say nothing in favor of East Africa for a very simple reason, I know nothing of it. I have read about Uganda and Kilimanjaro and the other countries in the neighborhood of the district in question, what every cultured European is bound to have read on the subject. I admit that I have read it but superficially. I cannot recommend East Africa. No Jew shall ever say, "I went to East Africa because Nordau sent me there." I will send no one there. All I can say is: East Africa is suggested to us; let us go into the matter. The second question is: Shall Zionism take up the question of the "Night Refuge?" I did not say Gorki's Night Refuge, where vagabonds meet, and, in a poetical frame of mind and the natural tone which makes Gorki's works so impressive, discuss the crimes they have committed together, or the murders planned for the future, and incidentally their love emotions and vague views on mankind.

I said—and I am sorry to see that this made no impression whatever on you, although you did not only hear it but have also since seen it printed—I said that our “Night Refuge” is to be an exceptional “Night Refuge,” it is to be at the same time a refuge and a means of education. (Cheers.) The Jews who come to our refuge will receive more than a piece of dry bread and a wooden bench for their bed. They will enter it as vagrants, and they will be made citizens while they live in it—Jewish citizens, not for East Africa or any other country, but for Zion. What is it you are doing at present? What does your Zionist agitation consist of? Does it consist in making yourselves conspicuous by meeting here? (Sensation and murmurs.) If necessary I shall say yet harder things to you. You devote yourselves to the work of educating Zionists in every country of the world, to making citizens of a chaotic mass of people. What do you do, but found colonies, in order to carry on your work of education more thoroughly, more completely, to keep your goal in sight more consistently. (Cheers.)

One of the speakers, Herr Diesenhof, for whom, by the way, I have great personal sympathy, made a remark with which I am familiar. He said, "It is not a question of Jews, but of Judaism." Judaism without the Jews! Why do you not go to a spiritualist meeting with this phrase? You will not succeed with it among the living, who wish to see life before them and around them. (Cheers.) Although I am not subject to the 15 minutes limit, I shall submit to it. I request your attention for three more minutes only. It has been suggested that we are using our means, which were provided under so many difficulties, for preparatory colonization, so that nothing will be left for our final goal. It seems to me that there is no fear whatever of this. It is not proposed to use the funds of our Colonial Trust, the National Fund, and contributions which we may receive for Zionist purposes. (Cheers.) The only thing that would be justifiable would be the sending of a committee of investigation, which would not require considerable financial sacrifices. But this would be the only financial sacrifice that would be required of the treasury of the Zionists. (Cheers.)

What are the risks if you decide to constitute a Commission to which you give instructions to study the plans submitted to them by the Actions Committee, and all explanation connected therewith, and perhaps also to extend their investigations to the conditions of colonization offered by the country in question? The Commission will never be entitled to make any final decisions. If necessary another Congress will be convened to make such decisions. The Jewish people shall make them, through an assembly of their voters. (Enthusiastic cheers.) But in the meantime you will fulfill two duties by electing a committee which would discuss the question submitted to you. Yon know that I am not a member of the Actions Committeee, I