Does she love you, and do you think you will love her?” The eldest boy burst into tears at this question and said, “Father, you are going to give us a stepmother!” Your confidence is of the same nature. We tell you on every possible occasion, we repeat it ad nauseam—for, as stylists, we are not fond of tautology; we consider tautology the poorest makeshift of bunglers, and we think that we need not consider ourselves bunglers—we tell you that our goal remains the same; our goal is Zion; we stand and fall by the Basle programme. The Basle programme can be destroyed by force, and we can be disabled by force, but we will never deviate from the Basle programme as long as it is in existence and as long as we are able to use our powers.
Yet you say, “We have every confidence in you, therefore we assume that you will surely not carry out the Basle programme.” (Cheers.) You fear that, if so much is said about a colony in East Africa or elsewhere, that a substitute for Zion is to be given to you. That is confidence with singular reservations, and based on hypotheses. Rest assured that no one will depart from the Basle Programme by even a hair’s breadth. What is it that you expect? If we except the martyr’s death, which has not yet been asked of us, can you have a greater proof of sincerity than a man who owns a good boat and has built a good bridge, who begins by burning his ship, destroying his bridge and saying, “Now I must stand and fall where I am.” This has been done. Those whom you call your leaders and whom you assure of your confidence have done it. They have burnt their ships and destroyed their bridges. They cannot go back; going back means drowning. Yet you say, “You have not been sincere with us.” You wish to somehow induce us to admit that Zion is not indispensable. I will not further describe such a course. (Cheers.) And now that I have proved myself to be a spirited Jew and have expressed my sentiments, we will do what I proposed in my first speech, we will discuss the question in a dispassionate and businesslike spirit.
I will only mention the chief points of the discussion which took place concerning the constitution of a Commission. Some of the things uttered were so attractive that they ought to be mentioned for purely artistic reasons. (Laughter.) There should be some brightness in this rather sad and melancholy discussion. Herr Wortsmann did not speak of the Commission; he took for granted that we will emigrate to East Africa, and attacked the supposed emigration with all the heat of the emotion which he felt. He was afraid that we might carry civilization to that wild country, that therefore there was no need for us to be grateful to England; that, on the contrary, England ought to be grateful to us, as it would be our task to transform the desert into a cultivated land. There has been a slight confusion of ideas. He must have been under the impression that we intend to emigrate to Siberia or to Sachalin. (Laughter.) It is true that those who work there do not work for themselves. (Laughter.) If a desert is transformed into cultivated country there those who do the work do not profit thereby. (Hear, hear.) But if one works in a British Colony under a charter of self-govern-ment one works for oneself.
The great objection formulated by Herr Wortsmann amounts to this, “You want to send poor people to a part of the world where they can become rich? That is not to be endured.” I know a Russian story which will illustrate this, too. It appears that in Russia a coachman is thought all the more of the taller and fatter he is, the longer his beard is and the better he is dressed. (Laughter.) A poor mujik went to a grand and rich Russian and asked for employment. The man was dressed in torn sheepskins and looked starved, miserable and thin. He was given a post as coachman with ten roubles a month. After three months he was a gigantic person with a double chin, an enormous beard, very fat and dressed in a beautiful fur-lined coat. He went to his master and said, “I have done a great deal for you, and you owe me a debt of gratitude. I came here miserable and shaky, ragged and starved. Now I am big and strong and handsome. For these things, I repeat, you owe me a debt of gratitude and you must raise my salary.” (Laughter.) This is an illustration of Herr Wortsmann’s points of view. Dr. Levin reminded us of Argentina and other settlements where Jews have been sent, not by Zionists it is true.
He asked us, “What is the difference between the proposal which you have made and those other proposals which Zionists have always opposed and declared to be quite insuffi-
