The Executive Committee, which commenced these inquiries, may conclude them in the way it finds the most politic without conflicting with our settled programme. The idea that the British Government is likely to be offended by the inability of Zionists to avail themselves of the offer made does little justice to the diplomatic ability of Dr. Herzl, who received the offer; and it does less than justice to our English administrative officers, who would be the first to recognize that, in all loyalty to those who have associated themselves with the Zionist programme, we are bound to adhere to it. Dr. Herzl declined the offer when it was first made to him on that ground; and his position will be strengthened and not weakened by our putting him in the position to say that his personal opinion has been confirmed by this representative assembly. I urge, therefore, on the Congress that beyond the expression of our grateful acknowledgment of the generous consideration given to the Jewish national movement by the British Government, no further action be taken on the proposed East African scheme, but that it be left to Dr. Herzl to make the necessary representations in the proper quarters to explain our attitude as Zionists on this subject. We have not the power, even if we had the wish, to accept the offer of land in East Africa for the settlement of our people there, in place of their legitimate home in Palestine, toward which all our efforts have hitherto been directed; and I hope we shall say, with no uncertain voice, that it is also not our wish.
Dr. Max Nordau: In the course of the lengthy and somewhat heated discussion which has just taken place, I have frequently winced at certain opinions which have been expressed. Yet, on the whole, it has left me with a feeling of exaltation. The very length and force of the debate was the strongest and most convincing proof of the fact that as soon as the Zionist question is touched upon the deepest fountains of feeling start, well up, and break forth stormily. I am rejoiced to find you in this frame of mind. We feel deeply. That is well known and has been more than ever apparent in this discussion. And even if this is useless from the point of view of law and order, yet, all things considered, it did not harm our cause. At all events the emotion which has been so evident in your midst for the last two days is to me the most genuine proof that you have been unwavering in your fidelity to Zion and that you will also transmit this same feeling to your children.
But now I beg that you will pardon me for saying that in my opinion you were too sensitive, and that your emotion was beside the mark, thus laying yourself open to misapprehension.The question you have dealt with during the past two days practically resolves itself underthree separate headings, which, however, have been much confused. From minds schooled inthe Talmud, it might well have been expected that these separate questions would have beendisentangled and set forth clearly and precisely. As, however, to my surprise, this has notbeen achieved—most certainly not by our opponents—I feel obliged to take this duty uponmyself, though I confess that I do so with great trepidation, as it is some time since I was anardent student of the Talmud, and as a Talmudist I scarce dare argue even the weakest ofyou. What is the point at issue here? Simply replies to these three questions:
(1) Is a Commission to be nominated merely for the examination of a given question,or for the purpose, further, of looking into other matters?(2) Are we to start for East Africa?(3) Must, and may, Zionism discuss the question of a "Night Refuge?"
As I, unfortunately, used this expression inadvertently in the discussion, and as it seems to have been thoroughly and completely misunderstood by you, I shall take the liberty of still using it, but I will explain it later on. Where the Night Refuge is to be founded is yet another question, and it devolves on you to find an answer. Nearly all our speakers, even the bitterest opponents, began by expressing their confidence in our leader, Dr. Herzl. Many of them, mostly cultured Russians, know Tolstoy. In one of the most touching parts of his writings, the recollections of his childhood and his youth, he relates an incident which I have never forgotten. It appears that his father had lost his first wife and was surrounded by a family of small children, who could not do without a mother. He thought of marrying again. Bu:- one day a governess appeared on the scene and was introduced to the children. The governess was singularly affectionate to the children, more than governesses usually are when they first come to a house. The father asked his children, “How do you like your new governess?”