The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
245printed page
scan 46 of 80

to move further or try to settle them in small colonies, it is not our business to co-operate with them, though it is probably their business to co-operate with us, since I feel sure that some part at least of their funds and activities would be more effective if linked with our movement. It would be fatal, if, to gratify an impatient demand for a proof of our practicality, we dropped our large idea, and became the rival of these tinkering associations, which would simply hand on the Jewish Question to posterity, much as we received it from our ancestors.

Statesmen, like Nature, cannot be too tender over the individual life: they must serve the type. It is worth while letting the Judenschmerz—the pain of eighteen hundred years—last a little longer, rather than that we should be turned aside from our slow measures for its radical cure, to administer the quack medicines of sentimental philanthropy. If we consider that half of our people lies penned in the towns of the Russian Pale, forbidden to expand industrially and agriculturally in accordance with the natural growth of population, we see at once that the poverty and suffering must by an inexorable law far outrun any pursuing means of mere beneficence. It is politics alone that can solve a political problem.

Even the bill of damages for Kishineff does not seem—to a cold-blooded economic analyst—the affair of Zionism. We have not on our conscience the responsibility of having tried to keep the Jews in Russia. For seven years we have been demanding that a home of refuge be prepared for our unfortunate brethren. We are here to prevent Kishineffs, not to cure them. We cannot turn aside, even in the most hysteric moments, from our great task, which needs all our energies and funds, and more than all our funds.

But even the cold-blooded analyst's heart would prevail over his brain, were we the only Jewish organization. Fortunately, there is not only Zionism, there are the charitable institutions.

After some discussion on Jochanan ben Zaccai, the sitting was adjourned.

TUESDAY AFTERNOON SITTING.

The question whether a Commission should be appointed to consider the offer of the British Government for an autonomous settlement of Jews in East Africa was opened for discussion. During the debate, in which each speaker was limited to fifteen minutes, strong approbation was expressed on the Russian side whenever the necessity of striving for the possession of Palestine, as being the aim of Zionism, was expressed. In fact, at the end of the sitting, which, interrupted for a short time, lasted until nearly midnight, there was a friendly demonstration in favor of Palestine, many delegates continually singing the “Hatikvoh,” which expresses the hope of Zionists for the return to the Land of Israel.

Herr Rosenbaum declared that there was the question whether Palestine could be had.He thought it could. The will of the people was able to accomplish a great deal, and they were,besides, not ready. Their duty was, therefore, at present to develop the forces of Zionism.

Mr. Cyrus Sulzberger drew attention to the fact that over a million of Jews had emigrated to the United States and Great Britain from Russia, Roumania and Galicia during the last twenty years. Could this population, especially in New York, be still increased without giving rise to anti-Semitism? There was already the Alien Immigration Commission in England, and there were the restrictive immigration laws in America. Was it not therefore their duty to provide some other place of refuge for the Jews? The basis of the note addressed by the Government of the United States to Roumania was that the emigrants from that country were not a desirable addition to the population. Let the Congress, therefore, not pin its faith too strongly to America; and when the opportunity for amelioration offered itself, let them embrace it.

It was then agreed that in view of the many speakers each one was to be limited to ten minutes.

Dr. Wortsmann thought they had to be thankful to Dr. Herzl, who had done so much, but he had not necessarily to follow him to East Africa. They could not have this as well as Palestine. They were, indeed, grateful to the English Government, but it must be remembered that the Jews would also be useful to the English as a colonizing body.

Dr. Bernstein-Kohann believed that they should not grasp at East Africa. Of course, hungry and sick Jews would demand something from them, but they were there not only to attend to the sick but also to the healthy. He asked the acceptance of the resolution which the