The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
244printed page
scan 45 of 80
244
THE MACCABÆAN.
October, 1903.

over the world, we are always liable to find our victories undone, and the positions we have gained captured by anti-Semitism. We have seen this danger threatening us even in free England.

One great cause of our perpetually slipping back arises from the aspect under which a homeless ubiquitous people is seen by the nations with which they are interfused. This aspect is a horizontal aspect, whereas each people among which we dwell sees itself perpendicularly. To explain myself, every German, Frenchman or Englishman knows very well that his people consists of descending and graduated strata of citizens, ranging down from Cabinet Ministers and the nobility, to paupers and criminals. But the Jews are viewed as a homogeneous group, horizontally spread out, all rich and ruining the nation, or all poor and clogging it, as the morbid fancy of the moment may dictate. One Jewish murderer casts a taint of blood over the race, while every other people hangs its murderers regularly without any forfeiture of self-respect. So well aware are the Jews of this fallacy, that they almost share it, as, for example, in their horror of the intrusion of one Jewish villain into a work of fiction.

Among the economic losses due to the lack of soil, the loss of men is not the least; for men are after all the true riches of a country. I am not speaking merely of the myriads washed away by the waters of baptism, but of the men of distinction who are the salt of the race. In Palestine, although Judaism was the national religion, there were at least four varieties of it, some sufficiently apart to amount to quite different religious conceptions. Thus in Palestine there was room for men of every school of religion, and even if they had dropped religion altogether, they could still have remained patriots. When Palestine was lost and became metaphorically incorporated in the religion, not only were large parts of the religion fossilized by being thus removed from the vital influences of reality, but the resulting platform of a mere religion proved too small to afford a standing-place to all the sons of Israel, especially as the thoughts of men went widening with the process of the suns. Hence, the loss of men like Spinoza, who, stepping off the narrow religious platform, found themselves outside Jewry, whereas in a land of our own, such men in future, instead of being excommunicated, would still find themselves among their own brethren. Since neither birth nor marriage now definitely determines who is a Jew and who not, the chronicler of Judaism is reduced to the test of whether a man is buried with the Jews. We take our census in our cemeteries. But the test of Judaism must be not death but life: how a man lives, not how he is buried. The non-Jew, Zola, unhappily dead since our last Congress, was a truer Jew than many a born, married and buried Hebrew.

THE SOUL IS GREATER THAN THE SOIL.

It has been obvious that the economic analysis of the evils of homelessness, which I now bring to a conclusion, applies to our position, not merely as a people without our own ancient country, but a people without any country whatever. And, although no country can vie with Palestine as the goal of our aspirations, yet there is no soil under the sun which, if only it were Jewish, would not ultimately wipe out all the physical and spiritual evils I have enumerated. The soul is greater than the soil, and the Jewish soul can create its Palestine anywhere, without necessarily losing the historic aspiration for the Holy Land.

It is obvious that in saying these evils would be entirely wiped out I am stating an abstract proposition, which in the world of reality would be modified by the fact that considerable sections of our race will always remain settled elsewhere. But their burdens, too, would be largely reduced and their dignity increased by the existence of a central home.

Even in our Palestine, new or old, certain evils would of course remain. They are the evils which I have already set aside as incidental to all peoples, though, as I said at the start, we should hope to minimize even these.

BESIDES ZIONISM—THE CHARITABLE INSTITUTIONS.

To those institutions which grapple with them now, in the lands of our Exile, we extend our blessing. To those which potter with the work that we try to do in a large political way, we are not antipathetic so long as they do practical good to unfortunate cases, and do not deliberately set themselves to counteract our line of action. But whether they help immigrants