The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
243printed page
scan 44 of 80

my theme is charity, may I compare the argument that it is better to have no country of our own so as to have nothing to administer or to lose to that used by a figure of my own creation—the King of Schnorrers? That illustrious personage, so proud of his long descent, was asked by his henchman, Yankele, for his daughter's hand. But the King of Schnorrers, discovering that Yankele occasionally worked, was horrified at the idea of intrusting his daughter's happiness to a man whose income rested on so uncertain a foundation as work. Work, he pointed out, was never sure. There were slack times and busy times. Industries declined and fell. Even riches were not secure, for rich men grew poor. In a world of flux only the Schnorrer . stood stable. Whatever wealthy men were ruined, others always sprang up to schnorr from. If this analogy was rather hard on the Jew, inasmuch as he is not a beggar but a paying guest of the nations, amid the ebb and flow of which he would on this theory preserve an immorta! existence, it is no unfair summary of the argument that one is perpetually hearing for shirking the responsibilities of independent nationhood. Under economic analysis these responsibilities, so far from being evaded, prove to be actually multiplied. Our language difficulties at this Congress in which so much time and energy are spent in translating every resolution into four or five languages are an exact symbol of the multiplication of difficulties and the economic waste produced by lack of a Jewish land.

To adopt with new significance the language of Jochanan ben Zakkai, "Unhappy nation, you would not offer half a shekel for the Temple, and therefore you must pay thirty shekels to the State." These thirty shekels are paid in every shape—pecuniary, spiritual and physical. The position in which the Jews place themselves by being an isolated clan in an alien environment is one too difficult for human nature. Everything they do in so unnatural a position leads to false results. The assimilation, for example, which Jewish pietists denounce, is—even in its extreme form of changing Jewish names—really a sign of civic virtue. The desire to obey general laws and approximate to a general standard, affords us the surest basis for building up a law-abiding people on a soil of our own. Just as dirt is merely matter in a wrong place, so certain Jewish vices will become Jewish virtues in a Jewish environment. Similarly, all those benefactions of Jewish millionaires which are the result of assimilation (like Mr. Mosely's supplying England with Industrial and Educational Commissions, and Mr. Pulitzer's endowing New York with a school of journalism, while their own race is writhing in torment) would naturally go to enrich their own people. In the reports of Alien Commissions these benefits reaped from the alien are never mentioned. The Jew's long centuries of labor in building up capitals and states, with no final profit to himself, make the Jew fill the only Christian rôle in economic history.

THE LACK OF A SOIL AND ECONOMIC WASTE.

As millions of Jews still keep the Saturday Sabbath, the double day of rest is another form in which they pay the thirty shekels. We could almost rebuild a State out of the cost of the Sabbath. I have not even taken into the account the tragic results of this sublime sacrifice in restricting the Jew in a foreign milieu to a few occupations. Consider, too, the economic waste in all the forced migrations of the wandering Jew. Our traveling expenses exceed those of any other nation. Though without a fleet, we keep employed a fleet of ships from year's end to year's end, the cost of which might have provided a Jewish navy. As for a Jewish army, it is divided among the armies of every country, for each and all of which we shed our blood. This does not prevent us from having more fights with rioters in every country. Add the bills of damages which we are always being asked to pay. For though we may settle ourselves in some particular country, we do not escape ubiquitous responsibility. In military language, we have to defend a frontier without limits. Then there are the political fights which we have to carry on in every country for our emancipation. And the irony of our fighting lies in this, that it is hopeless from the start. The Boers fought to be Boers, and victory would have preserved their national characteristics. But for Jews, success in being admitted to all the privileges of Englishmen, Frenchmen and Germans, only results in washing out their national characteristics. Thus it is a case of heads I lose, and tails you win. The only successful fighting that can be done to preserve the Jewish race is to place it on a soil of its own. Carrying on our fight all