The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
240printed page
scan 41 of 80
Facsimile · scan 41 of 80
Scan of p. 240
Text · transcribed from the scan

Israelite and which was the Jewish Colonization Association, might furnish an interesting prize competition to some popular newspaper. Both subsidize schools all over the world, and are engaged in miscellaneous philanthropy for developing the Jews in the countries they inhabit. This is the more remarkable, inasmuch as we have it over Baron de Hirsch’s own signature that in founding the Jewish Colonization Association he projected something entirely different from any existing institution. The chief difference in their working is that the Alliance is eager to encourage literature, and the Jewish -Colonization Association to encourage lawyers, that the Allıance nıhlishes halance sheets and the Tewish Coalonizatınn Assoriation does not.

But speaking more seriously—for the President of the Jewish Colonization Association now declares himself devoted to colonization—I trust that the moment Zionism is able to show the world a practicable scheme of colonization, the Jewish Colonization Association will hasten eagerly to sink the greater part of its resources and the greater part of its activities in our movement. For my part I have not the faintest animosity against its members as individuals. Some of them, indeed, I admire enormously, and I am certain that there is not one who will ultimately oppose any scheme, the largeness of which answers to the true conception of Baron de Hirsch, with an even more practical chance of success than his own tentative efforts. Baron de Hirsch was the father of Jewish colonization on a large scale. But it is now nearly thirteen years since this child of his was born in 1891. Soon it will be Barmitzvah, and the Hirsch Trustees can then send it out to us, to go on with its own manly self, with the orthodox benediction.

ברוך שפטרני מענשו שלוה.

"Blessed be he who hath freed me from the responsibility for this child." All that it needs now is a handsome Barmitzvah present.

Were the colonization that we meditate ever to become practicable in Palestine itself, our success would mean the supersession of the Chalukah, and the absorption of the many societies —German, Austrian, Danish, Swedish, etc., etc., devoted to Palestine Colonization. Even under present conditions they would do better to sink themselves in our movement. But if they plead that they wish to do definite small pieces of work, it is not necessary to declare war against them, but it is necessary to guard ourselves against imitating them, and against yielding to the cheap temptation of proving ourselves practical at the cost of our large idea, which is the only really practical method in the long run. A similar remark applies to the recently formed Jewish Oriental Colonization Society, which is economically a diffusion of Jewish forces, however praiseworthy the results it might achieve on a small scale.

CHARITY SUPERSEDED.

The Jewish schools of London are a glaring example of charity that would be superseded on a Jewish soil. The country at large provides elementary education, but Jews in addition to paying the education rate are philanthropically taxed for specifically Jewish schools. So lacking, however, in general clarity, is Jewish communal politics in London that the additional Jewish rate is frequently paid when the State itself, as a matter of routine, would defray the expense of Jewish education, and, in a policy of wisdom, even staff the Board schools with Jewish teachers. For in certain areas the State schools become Jewish merely because there are no Christians to go into them. In fact, there are almost as many Jewish schools formed by local accident as by conscious Jewish charity, while many more Jewish children are trained in Board schools than in voluntary Jewish schools. We even get the anomaly of Government schools entirely staffed and attended by Jews, while voluntary Jewish schools supported by Jewish contributions to preserve a Jewish atmosphere are partly staffed by Christians. Undoubtedly these communal Jewish schools, the historic survivals of an earlier educational period, and a far narrower Ghetto, should be ceded to the Government, and their funds left free for other Jewish charities. But these considerations belong to that aspect of Jewish charities namely, their lack of unification, which I have been compelled to set aside in the present paper. Nor will I do more than suggest how much of the energies of our Board of Guardians and other charities are frittered away upon immigration problems entirely due to our lack of a soil.