The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
236printed page
scan 37 of 80

urally there is a great deal, a very great deal for the Jewish people to do—urgent, less urgent, necessary, useful or simply desirable, though at present not essential matters, require attention. All tasks of this category must be referred to private enterprise. Let individuals and associations devote their surplus energies and resources, if they believe they have a surplus, to the consideration of these matters.

THE CHANGES ZIONISM WILL EFFECT.

Zionism must strictly avoid any division of its forces! Its sole programme must be: Development of the internal organization of the movement for the purpose of engaging the attention of the Powers to the Jewish Question, and meanwhile the establishment of a refuge for our homeless brethren.

The effects of this Jewish national policy, if you accept it and loudly proclaim it, will immediately become apparent and not only when it has wholly or partly been realized. The worldwill respect us when it sees us no longer oppressed, but standing upright. The Jew-haters willprobably remain Jew-haters, but the honorable individuals among them will disclose their hostility in a chivalrous manner, for only a coward is not ashamed of engaging otherwise thanchivalrously with an opponent who, with a big cockade of a visible color in his hat, fights for hislife in the daylight and in the open field! So Zionism—not later, but now—alters the two-score centuries' sign of Jewry from minus to plus, substitutes deeds for sufferance, and teachesthe world to recognize in the ostensibly commercially active people an active people in anothersense! (Loud applause, lasting several minutes.)

MONDAY AFTERNOON SITTING.

The chair was taken by Dr. Max Nordau.

Dr. Gronemann, in the name of the German delegates, proposed that the report of the Actions Comite and the balance sheet should be discussed without reference to the British offer.

Dr. Awinowitzky considered that the proposals brought forward by Dr. Herzl were of such importance that he thought they should be protected against any unfair criticism.

Dr. Herzl replied on behalf of the Actions Comite. In the composition of the report of the Actions Comite, they had, of course, to rely on the reports of the various organizations. The Actions Comite could not give the number and activity of the various groups. As regards the position of the Actions Comite as Council of the Jewish Colonial Trust, the Comite had taken its office very seriously. Concerning the El Arish project, the negotiations were unsuccessful because the impossibility of cultivating the land was shown, owing to a lack of water. It was the view of the Egyptian Government that only such a colonizing scheme should be undertaken which promised to be a success, and in which the colonists would not become a burden to the Egyptian Government; hence the expedition. There had been a proposal to bring water to the land by artificial means, but it would have to be provided from the Nile, and the Egyptian Government could not afford to permit this. The scheme therefore had to be given up. There was nothing to be expected from colonization on a small scale. The aim of the Zionists could not be obtained by money only, but through the national idea. He was pleased to say that he had been in communication with the Jewish Colonization Association during the year, and had found it favorable to his ideas. Those who represented the J. C. A. had declared themselves ready to co-operate if the Zionists should be successful in creating a firm basis for the work to be undertaken. It was therefore necessary that they should all unite their forces.

This speech by Dr. Herzl was accompanied by much cheering and occasional scenes. He sharply criticised Dr. Nossig and Herr Trietsch, the latter of whom he termed, amidst loud laughter, as "a Baron Hirsch without money." Ultimately, a vote of confidence in the Actions Comite was passed by acclamation.

Professor Gottheil asked in what form the Russian Government had given the assurance Dr. Herzl referred to. Mr. Cyrus L. Sulzberger inquired as to the publication of the papers connected with the English offer.

Dr. Herzl answered that he had a written document from the Russian Government, but