The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
232printed page
scan 33 of 80

claim it as a great service rendered by Zionism that it has put an end to the humbug about beinghappy and contented, and to the comedy of gratitude. (Loud cheers.) From the very begin

DR. MAX NORDAU.

We are an old historical people, numbering nearly twelve millions. We believe we are as good as any other people on the face of the earth. (Loud applause.) If necessary we can prove

it. With diminishing exceptions we have been pursued with hate or, at any rate, with disfavor and distrust. Here we are explicitly denied the most elementary human rights. There they are granted us on paper, but for the most part withheld in practice. We refuse to live any longer under these conditions. We cannot compel men's loves, but we can demand justice because we are God's creatures. (Loud cheers.) It is, however, unjust for us to be treated as pariahs, or at the best as second-rate citizens, and everywhere as reluctantly tolerated foreign intruders. We are not pariahs, and do not wish to be handled as such. We want to be in Palestine citizens with full privileges (loud and protracted applause) with the generally recognized historical rights of original inhabitants, and we ask the Governments to help us attain this goal.

TAKING AND ASKING.

That, I repeat, may appear a small matter to contemporary observers; as a matter of fact it is a turning-point in the history of the Jewish people.

We have asked. Since the world began there have ever been but two methods of obtaining anything. These two methods may be succinctly stated in the words: Take it or ask for it.

We are neither in a position nor desire to take anything, so we are thrown back upon the second method, that of asking. It is strange, but literally true, that before the rise of Zionism we absolutely did not ask. Among ourselves we heaved deep sighs, expressed longing desires in prose and verse, pressed each other's hands with significant looks, but we have never stood before the Powers, and in an unequivocal form openly and distinctly stated what we wanted. We can neither reproach ourselves nor others on that account. The Jewish people was in a state of chaos; it was unorganized; it was a human swarm; it did not even know itself what it wanted; it had no representatives competent to speak in its name; and as it did not know itself what it wanted, it was only natural that the Governments remained in ignorance. To have altered all that appears little, but in reality it is very much. We had asked! We had asked that Palestine—due provision naturally being made for safeguarding the suzerain rights of the Sultan, and equally naturally for the extra-territorialization of the Holy Places to which all Chris-