The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
224printed page
scan 25 of 80
224
THE MACCABÆAN.
October, 1903

people who snugly believe they have done their duty when, after reading in the paper of a mediæval massacre of Jews, they send a modest contribution to the relief fund. Even granting that they have given honestly according to their means, with money alone they have not done enough. Money will not give back life to the dead, health to the crippled, parents to their orphan children. And how can such alms assuage the anxiety of those who, if they be not actually physically affected, nevertheless live on under similar situations? Their condition is still precarious.

We Zionists only make use of these arguments with great reluctance. It goes against the grain to make political capital out of disasters, and to use the wretchedness of the poorest creatures for the purposes of agitation. But an expression must go forth from this spot of the pain and indignation with which we learnt of the horrible occurrences at Kishineff, and of the grief we experience that Jews should live under such conditions. We will honor the memory of the fallen, care for those they have left behind, and then we shall not waste our time with useless demonstrations, but extend our lively sympathy to the living.

For the bloody days of the Bessarabian town shall not make us forget that there is many another Kishineff, even beyond the borders of Russia. The spirit of Kishineff hovers over every place where Jews are physically or morally afflicted, dishonored, impoverished, because they are Jews. Let us save those that can still be saved!

It is high time. Whoever sees the visible tokens must appreciate the fact that an extremely serious change for the worse has taken place. We Zionists prophesied this change years ago—and now that it has come we feel it most.

EMIGRATION AS A MEANS OF SALVATION

In the last two decades of the nineteenth century emigration was regarded in Jewish circles as a means of salvation. That was all very well if everything else were disregarded—the misery of the emigrants, the cruelty of the new conditions upon which they entered ill-prepared, the national losses through ever new dispersions, and so on—it was satisfactory for just so long as the lands to which the immigration was directed did not protect themselves against this invasion of a desperate proletariat.

We are now entering upon a new epoch. The countries to which the immigration has hitherto been chiefly directed have begun to close their doors while, or because, Jewish distress in Eastern Europe is on the increase. And yet they are countries on whose high state of civilization it would be simply madness to cast any doubts. These States believe it to be necessary to place limits upon their customary humanity—I am not speaking ironically—and to deal politically with the Jewish Question, which for them is the question of Jewish immigration. Only among us Jews do many refuse in their fear to see therein a political measure. This fear will inspire us more with pity than with anger if we understand it aright. It is a panic-stricken emotion inherited from the Ghetto.

Meanwhile, events have taken their uninterrupted course. In England, the last hitherto entirely free asylum, a Royal Commission on Alien Immigration was appointed. It was the immigration of aliens, not to say of Jews, that was under ex-