The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 4 · October 1903
221printed page
scan 22 of 80
October, 1903.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
221

only buyer of grapes has always been the Baron Edmond de Rothschild, through his administration and for the last few years through the Jewish Colonization Association. Mr. Lewin-Epstein then gives the names of those interested in the sale of Palestinian wines, among whom are representative Jews of all classes. But it is not to be expected that much attention will be paid to facts by editors who do not recognize the right of freedom of expression in the public press. Nowhere will one find communications addressed to the editor, respectful in tone, signed by reputable men, totally ignored by the press, as is done by the Jewish press.

The rabbis who met in Cracow last month, passed resolutions condemning the revolutionary movement, in which many Jews participate. This resolution has brought out many protests from socialists throughout the Cracow district, who say that such action was ill-advised; from the very same sources comes condemnation of the oath against ritual murder, which, it is said, was unnecessary, for we need not swear that we are not cannibals. The orthodox rabbis seems to feel that it is incumbent upon them to stem the tide of radical sentiment, which, in their opinion, is at bottom of much of the present persecution in Russia. Russian delegates to the Basle Congress also expressed themselves to the same effect.

The number of Jewish students in the secondary schools of Roumania tends to diminish, owing to the stringent measures adopted by the educational authorities. Poverty has also some effect as a deterrent from attendance at colleges and universities. From day to day the condition of the Jews in Roumania becomes more and more intolerable.

Kishineff has produced much oratory, and many books. The Juedische Verlag gives a valuable account of the whole affair, finely printed and accurate in statement. In America the start was made with a book by a Mr. Stiles, in which the author, enthusiastically in favor of bettering the conditions of the Jews in Russia, attacked the Russian Government with passionate inaccuracy. The book had all the appearances of hasty compilation. Dr. Isadore Singer, who claims the proud

title of projector of the Jewish Encyclopedia, will have Funk & Wagnalls Company publish his book on Russia to be entitled “Russia Before the Bar of the American People.” It will be a compilation of a scholarly nature. Perhaps the best book will be Michael Davitt's book, “Within the Pale,” published by A. S. Barnes and Company. Mr. Davitt returned from Russia a thorough believer in Zionism, and his book will be a sane discussion of the events preceding the outbreak, an accurate description of the riots, and what he thinks to be the one solution of the problem.

Dr. Emil G. Hirsch, whose opinions may be taken as indications of the variable position of reform Judaism in America, often strikes home. In his judgment whatever havoc may have been wrought in American synagogues is due to insufficiency of theological preparation on the part of the leaders. Under the name of reform something has of late years been huckstered about which the reformers of forty years ago would have great difficulties to recognize as a development of their own programmes. They were all without exception under the consecration of a profound historical consciousness.

One example of many may illustrate the point. In their reconstruction of the ritual these reformers aimed at the preservation of the historical rhythm, so to speak, of the synagogal service. Their scholarly criticisms had enabled them to detach the original fundamental cast of the prayer-book from the mass of later accretions and this cast they with slight modifications retained in the modern service. Not so the younger set of would be reformers. It is difficult to distinguish their ritual from that of a neighboring Protestant Church. The old Jewish reformers, in their liberalism, were withal saturated with the Jewish spirit. The good old Jewish sanity and sobriety rang in every one of their utterances.

American citizens as such cannot obtain permission to excavate in the Turkish Empire, at least in Babylonia. For over three years a committee has tried to secure from the Turkish Government permission to excavate. The application was in all respects in conformity with the law of the Turkish Empire governing excavations. No permis-