The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
8printed page
scan 3 of 86
8
THE MACCABÆAN.
[July, 1903.

ter's insubordination is nothing short of a catastrophe. The integrity of family life is at stake, the morality of one generation at least, not to speak of the fate of Judaism. Unless the heart of the fathers is turned to the children, and the heart of the children to the fathers, the earth will be smitten with a curse. If parents and children can be prevailed upon to approach the subject of Judaism in the same loving spirit, then, no matter how far apart their conception of Judaism may remain, their other differences will be minimized, and a Jewish modus vivendi will be arrived at.

But is it possible for Jewish feeling to be restored or created anew by any system of education? Is the intellect the source of feeling? Can sweetness come forth out of the strong?

In other generations and other countries, the Jewish mother and the Jewish daughter were virtuous and valiant women, whose price is above pearls, though they knew of Judaism only what Jewish life taught them. But if they knew only that, they knew much. Moreover, what they learned from Jewish life, Jewish life afforded them the opportunity to give out again in the form of domestic ceremonial and communal, neighborly responsibilities. Before the days of woman's emancipation, Jewish life offered them a large sphere of activity. That old Jewish life seems not to bear transplanting to the soil of this country. What we need is to reproduce its atmosphere as nearly as can be in a new climate, country, and set of conditions, by interpenetrating ourselves with its fundamental principles. This is no new theory. It is what all nations do in their regenerative periods. They go back to their origins for unused material. It is what Israel did again and again, and all the time, in his wanderings, with their constantly shifting problems. He refreshed himself at the sources from which those drank who had had the shaping of Jewish life in the first place—those, for instance, who held that the ignorant cannot be truly pious, and whose authority was at least as commanding as the authority of the obscurantist who gave woman the choice between ignorance and immorality. The Jewish heart has always starved unless it was fed through the Jewish intellect. This is the point at which the example of the reform movement is a warning. The failure of the confirmation service as the climax of woman's Jewish education was due to its having degenerated into an exclusive appeal to the sentiments.

That the exercise of the Jewish intellect stimulates Jewish self-consciousness and feeling is a commonplace in Jewish history. The new point is whether the exercise of the Jewish intellect is an esoteric privilege reserved for Jewish men; whether, in fact, Jewish women have a Jewish intellect. There is no Jewish doctrine on the point, I can safely assert without knowing the Jewish sources as one ought to know them before making ex-cathedra statements. But there is, as we have seen, a good deal of well-entrenched reactionary sentiment. Can this sentiment hold its own in the modern world? The secular education of girls, Jewish girls and others, has luckily come to stay. So much good has resulted from the stress of economic conditions. Now, education is one of the forces which refuse to heed the most imperious "so far and no farther." Intellectual faculties set free on many fields chafe against fetters imposed on other fields. The salvation of Jewish girls as Jewesses and, for the present at least, as fine specimens of womanhood, depends upon a proper alignment of their Jewish education with their secular education. In no less degree does the salvation of Judaism as a world power, the measure of respect it can exact, depend upon its alignment with genuine modern demands, and the utilization of all the intellect vouchsafed unto mankind, whether stored up in male or in female crania, undoubtedly is a genuine modern demand. Women, Jewish women among them, have conquered a place in public life where it was not accorded to them. That place they will occupy, let the reactionary say what he will. It remains with the leaders of education to confer upon them the power of filling the place worthily. During the last decade American communities have been making a bugbear of the feminization of Judaism, when they might have been better employed in concerning themselves about its emasculation, which is not synonymous with the other. If the fear of feminization ever becomes a reality, it will be because Jewish women are ignorant, not because they are too learned. It is a little learning that is dangerous in one sex as in the other. Nothing is more effective in conveying to women a sense of their natural limitations and a realization of their natural functions than a rounded, symmetrical education.