The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
44printed page
scan 39 of 86
44
THE MACCABÆAN.
[July, 1903.

The History and Causes of Anti-Semitism*

M. Bernard Lazare’s work is presented here in an English dress, fitting well on the whole. The following passage, explanatory of this statement, is fairly representative: “The works of Jewish philosophers had spread and exercised considerable influence on the scholasticism of the time; men like Alexandre de Hales had read Maimonides (Rabbi Moses) and Ibn Gebirol (Avicebron), and they bore the impress of the teachings exposed by the Guide of the Perplexed and the Fountain from Life.” (From p. 152.)

All the same we are glad to have the work in the present form, for it is a sane and accurate account of the workings of those who opposed the Jews from the earliest period in their history to our own day.

The chief causes of anti-Semitism, according to M. Lazare, are Jewish aloofness, consequently Jewish pride, and the belief on the part of the Jews that they are the elect, God's chosen folk in verity. From these M. Lazare derives all the other moving forces in anti-Semitism, so that it may well be said that did the Jews not hold aloof from others there would be no hatred of the Jews. Such reasoning as this is superficial, for there is enough of the impalpable in anti-Semitism to make one comprehend that it cannot be eradicated (as the facts prove) by Jewish chauvinism and comradery. But M. Lazare is right in assuming aloofness as the first premise, for from it resulted all the evils that befell Jewry. Because the Jews held themselves apart from other men, or rather, for the reasons which follow the Jews held themselves apart from other men, we have the prescriptions as to dress, "signs of infamy," the harsh laws and unsanitary ghettoes of the mediæval period in European history. M. Lazare, it should be remarked, desires to be impartial, just to the Jews and the anti-Semites, above all things. But is he quite right in ascribing an inordinate love of gold to Jews, a fondness for trafficking in money? It certainly existed but as the result of the decrees fulminated against European Jews by popes and Lateran councils which forbade the Jews from engaging in agriculture and owning land.

Particularly good is the chapter dealing with the anti-Judaic literature, the collections of disputations, of anti-Talmuds, etc., of the later middle and the earlier modern age. And it is quite interesting to note the vast quantities of anti-Christian literature, exegetical and polemical, the Life of Jesus, recently edited by Dr. Samuel Krauss, being an example.

A rather full account of the economic basis of anti-Semitism—there are many who lay a proper insistence on this all-important phase of the situation—and the communistic and revolutionary elements in Judaism, especially the ebjonim w anjavim of Isaiah, is given. Because the Jews have been malcontents, always on the side of the liberal, even the socialist statesmen, anti-Semitism has come into being. The statement is truthful, but the examples M. Lazare cites to support it are not happy. Disraeli was a Tory, Karl Marx a closet philosopher, Crémieux a supporter

* Anti-Semitism, its History and Causes, by Bernard Lazaro. Translated from the French. New York: The International Library Pub. Co.