Harum with Job and whatever Jewish history has been taken up has been sliced away into agreeable portions that may be swallowed in small doses.
But especially has this dilettante method of education been exalted to its highest plane in what is known as the Jewish Chautauqua Assembly, built on the idea of the American movement organized to educate the masses. This Chautauqua, however, does not educate the masses. As a matter of fact, it is as distant from the masses as are some of our uptown temples. The Jewish Chautauqua is a tribute to the efforts of one man, and, like all Jewish organizations, seems to be abandoning education in the real sense, and hitching its wagon to the glowing star of Jewish philanthropy. From the start it has been a temporist. It has pandered to the wilful caprice of those who, for the lack of some definite thing to do in this world, have become the victims of weariness and are searching for something to soothe their tired souls. Do I exaggerate when I say that the Jewish Chautauqua is an organization whcih has been traveling on a slack wire, zig-zagging on a wavering line, and the other end of the line is being held by its energetic Chancellor, who has directed it to any goal which has promised public attention? Its most pretentious work, of course, is the platform at the Summer resorts where the indifferent sojourner is angled for with the tempting bait of a lecture on Carlyle, on Gorky, or the Strenuous Life, or the Greatness of the Jewish People, or some such themes. It has subdivided Jewish history as well as Jewish life into titles. It has made the road to knowledge decidedly easy, for by its syllabi it presents subjects in a manner calculated to include, by suggestion at any rate, all phases of Jewish life.
In our philanthropic education one would suppose Jewish character would come underconsideration. But Jewish philanthropy, in its educational methods (barring, of course, theattempts to make mechanics or farmers of Jews), misses entirely the Jewish spirit, and avowedly so, for it seems to be the unexpressed intention of modern American philanthropists thatAmericanism and Judaism are irreconcilable, or, at least, run parallel to each other and nevermeet. Our philanthropists have determined on the suppression of anything distinctivelyJewish, because of the danger of Jewish assertiveness, which might imperil our security inthis country. As a result, it either demoralizes those who come in contact with it or it produces soul abortions, weak things, void of all purpose and of all strength. It twists the natureof children and takes away from them the background of immediate ancestral accomplishment.It makes of every Jewish child an intellectual and soul orphan, and paves the way to that greatdanger which is now imminent, the estrangement of parent and child in our congested quarters.
To conclude, then, the great lack of our Jewish spirit. We imagine that it is necessary for us to pass through an era of self-effacement in order to come out into the open field of equality. The result of such methods must be tragedy. domestic, social, and political. The result of such methods must be Jews who have contempt for Jewish life, for life has become with them a conscious imitation, and the reward of the good mimic is the luckless goal of assimilation. We have not developed American Jewish education, for the Jewish part of it has been ignored consciously, and if not ignored entirely has become a flambeau fed by the unmixable oil of foreign manufacture. We have looked with one eye on methods of adaptation and closed the other eye to the Jewish method; and we have become cross-eyed by reason of it, and truth is obscured, and sincerity is derided, and cowardice is applauded. Of all Jews, we in America are coming to recognize not the adventurous, the valorous, the bold spirit of individual assertion, but the insignificant and the commonplace. We are forgetting that the danger of anti-Jewish feeling in America is not half as fearful as the danger that our great Russian population shall become inspired with mediocre and subdued ideals.
America is the Jews' preparatory school in democracy. Here, if it is destined that we shall remain for some time to come, will the character of the Jews attain that refinement and strength which the nations of Europe have attempted to suppress. Here the Jewish people are intrusted freely with freedom, and here really, for the first time, the Jewish character meets the non-Jewish character through the intangible communication of personality, and if we are to sustain our right to racial separateness, for the better fulfillment of our natures,