The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
7printed page
scan 2 of 86
Facsimile · scan 2 of 86
Scan of p. 7
Text · transcribed from the scan

follows by consequence. This is the history of enlarged educational opportunities for women—this is the iron logic to which the Jew bows as every other nationality bowed to it. If there is another current—that woman with broader education demanded and obtained broader opportunities—it is not the dominant current.

So much for secular education. As for the Jewish education of his girls, that, happily or unhappily, still depends upon the father's initiative. How does he show himself worthy of his privilege? Does he square their Jewish education by the secular standards of public education?

Nothing he sees in America is calculated to weaken the feeling that the conservation of Judaism is safer with the women of the old school than with women of the new. On the other hand, his traditional inertia in the matter of woman's education is re-enforced by American conditions, which put an education ready-made at the door of every citizen. He has but to stretch forth his hand and draw it within. Being relieved of responsibility for the character of the one sort of education, he has the less power to shape the other sort. His faculty for feeling responsibility for the education of his household is in a measure atrophied. He shirks the whole question. If things go ill, his daughters grow up untaught heathen. If things go well, they drift into a Sunday School; or that abomination, a Jewish mission school —schools to which, if the worst came to the worst, he would not entrust his sons. His daughters, however, are only women, who would be better off without education, therefore, an inferior education will do for them. So the Jewish girl's Jewish education is no better taken care of in a land of golden opportunities than in a crowded Jewry of the East, where she at least lives an intense Jewish life with its manifold educational influences.

Close upon the heels of neglect follows retribution. The tale has been told over and over again of the wide chasm between Jewish parents and their children in this country. The first rift in the relation in many cases is made by the mere fact of secular education or by its peculiar American character. That is inevitable. The new language were enough to account for it. The breach so begun is widened by the reversal of economic relations. When mothers and fathers find themselves dependent upon the earnings of their young sons, it is bad enough. Whatever shrinking they feel from the situation in the case of their boys, is intensified with their girls. It is revolting to their sense of the fitness of things to have their daughters go forth as bread-winners. In proportion as their instincts of delicacy are outraged, the bonds of discipline are relaxed. The elders creep into their shell in dumb disgust or despair, the youngsters lose love and respect for a home without a spiritual head. Unless the parents are robust in character beyond the ordinary, or the girls finely attuned beyond the ordinary, the estrangement becomes irremediable when the girls are still in their early teens. Significantly enough, if the girls find a voice for their grievance, they formulate it in Jewish terms. They realize darkly that unyielding outer conditions are answerable for difference in standards of education and of living. Such differences cast no reflection upon the victims. It is otherwise with Jewish forms. Whatever opposition and friction they engender proceeds from a voluntarily assumed attitude, which might be abandoned if the elders were not so stubborn and unsympathetic. The remedy, however, lies, not in abandoning it, but in making it more intelligently earnest, more vital. But earnestness is not synonymous with the exercise of parental authority. The time has passed when the argument holds: So your forefathers did, so I do, so you must do. The forefathers did many things which the parents of this generation have been forced to sacrifice on the altar of necessity, and the children are not slow to transfer the same logic to other domains. The parents must argue, not with their children, but with themselves: So my forefathers felt, so I feel, so I must and so I shall, with God’s help, teach my children to feel.

In this particular of Jewish defection, as in that of economic readjustment in the family, the relation between parents and daughters suffers a more serious disturbance than the relation between parents and sons. Girls once brought to the point of rebellion are more radical than boys, or they appear so. A woman's revolt affects the home, a man's the synagogue. There can be no doubt which is the more alarming and offensive. To the Jew, accustomed from time immemorial to regard Jewish women as symbols of loyalty, a daugh-