The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 1 · July 1903
15printed page
scan 10 of 86
Facsimile · scan 10 of 86
Scan of p. 15
Text · transcribed from the scan

Our brethren have imported from the Ghettos they came from many unamiable peculiarities. Why should they not retain the good and laudable qualities of those quarters? Visit the large Jewish settlements in Russia and you will find that parents nowadays, under the most unfavorable material and political circumstances, pay for each boy at the Jewish primary schools, 25 roubles for a זמן, a term of six months, that people of means pay for a competent teacher of Talmud, 100 roubles a year, and more.

Thousands of our immigrant brethren in this country are well to do and have even accumulated much wealth. In New York and other large cities of the Union hundreds of former peddlers and small tradesmen live now in palatial residences, own cottages in the finest summer resorts and live in grand style. They and their sons are extravagant in their apparel, their wives and daughters wear expensive dresses and are the best customers of the jewelers. Why should they not manifest some liberality for the Jewish training of their children? They continually try to impress us that they are conservative and orthodox Jews; that the preservation of Judaism is the aim and purpose of their lives. How do they prove that they are in earnest with their emphatic assurances? If their conservatism consists merely in keeping intact the old ritual, not allowing any changes, even in abuses and unpleasant customs at the Synagogue and the Biblical and rabbinical dietary laws at the kitchen—a cheap conservatism indeed—then we must denounce their alleged piety as hypocrisy and self-deceit, and the Midrashic saying: נחבעין לעגל ונורנין נחבעין למשכן ונורנין ת ח ב ע ין that the Jew always opens his hand and purse for bad and good purposes alike does not hold true with the orthodox and conservative Jews of our adopted country.

Americanism is the watchword with them as it is with their children. I surely would be the last one to criticise them for being desirous of becoming Americanized in the lofty meaning of this term. They should, however, learn to know that Americanism does not mean the worship of the almighty dollar, the dancing around the golden calf. To Americanize life does not by any means imply to materialize, to coarsen life, to commercialize it. Why should they not learn a lesson from our Christian fellow-citizens who, with all their materialistic notions and ambitions, devote their attentions to their church by founding and endowing theological seminaries and libraries.

The only solution of the Jewish question is Zionism, without any reservation, industrial, agricultural, and political, a Jewish life, a Jewish language, in a Jewish land. I, too, arrived at this conclusion after much thinking and doubting and listening to arguments pro and con. The massacre of our brethren in Kishineff in the name and for the glory of a powerful Christian denomination, the cynical explanations of this bestial butchery, made by the Russian Ambassador at Washington, and the infamous laudatory comments of the Russian Pan-Slavistic press on these atrocities have cured me, radically and totally, from the sweet hope that our modern civilization, based upon egotism and selfishness, will put a stop to Anti-Semitism, and its brutalities. Our mission is not to be pillaged and robbed and slaughtered and butchered by drunken beasts.

But Zionism is only the structure of Israel's future. It cannot be erected and built up without a solid and firm foundation. This, again, cannot be laid without keeping up and fostering Jewish ideals and there is no Judaism without the historical Hebrew language.