Immigration The sittings of the British Problems Royal Commission on Alien Immigration have
The sittings of the British Immigration Royal Commission on Problems Alien Immigration have been rendered especially interesting by the Jewish evidence submitted in favor of the immigrants, which has, however, called forth more than the usual amount of attention on this side of the Atlantic, in view of the fact that Sir Samuel Montagu, incidental to his evidence, cast some slurs upon the American Jewish community. The
Jewish leaders in the States, with few exceptions, did not do their duty, and dreaded people coming for relief. They did not give relief in proportion to their wealth. Major Gordon quoted from one of the reports of the United Hebrew Charities, to show that the immigration into the United States was being overdone. But Sir Samuel replied that the condition of things there was different. The leading Jews
GENERAL ANDRE
phrases which have called forth the greatest amount of attention result from a question put by Major Gordon, who asked Sir Samuel Montagu whether the American Jews were not opposed to the immigration of their own people from Europe. In reply, Sir Samuel said:
"Yes. It is a very selfish policy, based on the fact that it is the Jews and the Jewish trades who suffer by the arrival of these people. But there are several Jews in America who have protested, and who favor the welfare of their Jewish co-religionists. He went on to say that the
M. CAVIAGNAC
were not so Jewish as to win the confidence of these people, who, consequently, liked to manage their affairs in their own way. With one or two exceptions, the Russian Poles had no confidence in the leading American Jews."
Sir Samuel Montagu has disturbed many of the New York dovecotes by his plain speaking. Although we think that he has overlooked the fact that anti-alien immigration legislation, as far as it goes in the United States, follows the line of a protective policy rather than meets the wishes or suffers