had been identified with the making of American Reform Judiasm and to admire energy for its own sake, even to the point of ignoring that it was and is sometimes misplaced. There leaked out here and there in these conversations, tidbits of the mental recantation which this old teacher had made, a plea against environment; such as, that only congregational ignorance had made the prayer book almost wholly English; a self-buttressing that Reform had stemmed the tide of Ethical Culture; a story of the revelation of Jewish existence that came when, accompanied by Emma Lazarus, the deceased went to aid the first refugees from Russia.
In the midst of all, a great conflict of life, an admission of the essential paradox that clothes every wanderer, a swelling of pride with thoughts of things German, an unquailing confidence in English solidarity, a pæan of praise at American prosperity, and out of the midst of all this, some heart note of things Jewish.
One could not sometimes help querying what kind of a revolution could such a man have instigated had the thought of a national Israel become clear to him, when he was still amongst the strong protagonists of American Jewish life? He himself did not feel any pause of life, reading the latest publications, annotating the newest developments of religious thought, and moving by a strange, soft spiritual light, which was distinctly part of the mental makeup of his individuality.
The last time he stood on a Zionist platform, it was on one created in the temple he had so long served, there to avow the passion that had moved his being; he stood there like some old, quivering prophet, moving both by the method and the matter of his utterance, telling by emotion so much more than can be said in the most skillful address. After that, he began his battle with Azrael, and on what seemed a good recovery, and in the last conversation the writer then had with him, Gustav Gottheil summed up unconsciously the thought of his life on what is certainly no ignoble message to Israel. He had gathered what had of late been doing in the Zionistic world, and giving the writer what proved to be a last grip of the hand, he said, “I do nothing now but think; and when I think it sometimes seems to me an impossibility to realize what we are striving for; but then, at the same time, I remember that we are an impossible people and that we have only existed by impossibilities. Sometimes we have called the overcoming of these impossibilities miracles, and after all, the Return would be something of a miracle. It will, therefore, be accomplished by something in the nature of a miracle. There is nothing greater, I think, than the reflection that our people are striving to perform a miracle.”
He who could not don armor and enter with youthful vigor into the fray, cheered us lustily on to battle. Such men inspire their generation and help us to see the worthy life. Their memories remain with our consciousness, urging and urging it on; and therefore the hackneyed phrase is true, "to live in hearts we leave behind is not to die."
May his kith and kin be consoled with the consolation which is as old as the Exile, "May He who sendeth comfort unto Zion comfort the mourners."