gaws. The Seder is not a ritual, and the Hagadah is not a recitation. They are feeling and emotion and consciousness of history. Passion, suffering, yearning and hope, intensely human thought, and deep spiritual longings; these are the elements that make and uphold the service of the Passover.
VARIOUS ZIONISMS-
THE Cincinnati Israelite observed in a recent issue: "There seem to be as many different conceptions of Zionism among the Zionists as there are sects in Christendom, and the Lord only knows how many of these there are. Will the Zionists please explain the cause for this disparity of opinion?"
It is not exactly the practice of the Israelite to publish the views of the other side. On the contrary, it is the one remaining Jewish journal in the United States which believes that it can stem the Zionist tide by making a dam of ridicule, scorn and sarcasm, and by keeping from its readers all pro-Zionist statements. Our explanation, since we shall not risk a refusal, must, therefore, be confined to our own pages.
Whilst we cannot determine what differing conceptions amongst Zionists demand explanation, we presume that the varying attitudes of Drs. Felsenthal, M. H. Harris and Max Heller, have in particular roused the attention of the Israelite; and if not, we freely admit that among our leaders there are also varying conceptions of the movement. This is most natural, most reasonable and the boast of Zionism. Appealing as we do to every shade of Jewish thought, to every class of Jews, offering a cardinal principle for the whole Jewish life, it is but natural that whilst each thinking man accepts that principle, he approaches it through his own medium of thought, that he couples with it the particular ideals with which he heretofore placed faith. Thus, we have the economic, the religious and the national Zionists, to name three distinct classes who seek the objective for three distinct reasons. The one because of persecution and economic misery, the second because of his faith in the religious future of a Jewish state, the third because he claims and seeks the completion of his national existence before all other things.
The important thing is the end they seek,
the medium is secondary. We cannot put aside the past, notwithstanding that we seek a new future; and we can believe that the greatness of the Jewish future depends upon the amalgam of all the ideas which move the modern Jewish world. If Zionism were not great enough to sustain all these modifications of thought, all the nuances of expression, it would certainly not be worth while the effort which is being put forth to make it succeed.
TO OUR CREDIT
THE Edinburgh Review is famous among the serious publications, political and literary. The last number contains an article, "Panslavism in the Near East," in which the writer discusses Zionism. The writer notes the increase of the Jewish population in Palestine and adds what it would be well to bring under the notice of those who talk so glibly of the "impossibility" of political Zionism: "This rapid increase, facilitated by the construction of the Jaffa-Jerusalem railway, has received its chief impetus from the persecutions to which the Hebrew race has of late been subjected in Eastern Europe. Most of the immigrants come from Russia, Hungary, Galicia and other parts of Austria and Germany. . . . Immigration continues apace under the auspices of the Alliance Israelite, which aione spends 1,000,-oco francs a year on the Hebrew colonies and schools in Turkey, and other philanthropic societies. The latest phase of this migration, known as the Zionist movement, has for its object to revive the Jewish State by purchasing Palestine from Turkey. The movement, though condemned by some as Utopian, and ridiculed by others as sentimental in origin, possesses considerable interest for the unprejudiced observer of Eastern affairs. No one who has watched its growth can doubt its practical importance." The reviewer then proceeds to relate the recent negotiations between Dr. Herzl and the Sultan, and concludes: "Although the Sultan is not prepared to grant all that his guest demanded, there is sufficient ground to believe, with Dr. Herzl, that the negotiations will most probably, at no distant time, lead to a conclusion satisfactory to the Sultan and the Zionists alike. This hope is strengthened by
