Galicia. The report covers fifty pages.It is a descriptive account of what theauthor saw and comes to no conclusions.He has, however, elsewhere since placedon record his opinion of the Jewish conditions in Eastern Europe and the needfor restricting immigration in theseterms: ‘The conditions under whichthese people live are not such as can beexpected to produce desirable recruitsfor our already conjested population.’During the sittings that immediatelyfollowed the case against the alien wasclosed, and the hearing of evidence inhis favor has begun. This evidence haspractically been arranged and marshalled by Mr. L. J. Greenberg, one ofthe Governors of the Jewish ColonialTrust, one of the most ardent Zionistsand an expert on the facts and figuresof the migration movement to England.No doubt much that has been saidagainst the Jews will be riddled throughand through.
But the temper of the times, which in the end will govern the issue, is well illustrated by the strangest editorial which has in modern times appeared in a Jewish journal. In "A Word to the Press" the London Jewish Chronicle of March 13 wrote:
The case against the aliens, which has dragged along through a score of sittings and an intricate maze of allegation and repetition, is at length closed; and yesterday, the case for the alien was begun. We sincerely trust that this part of the Commission's work will not be ignored by the general press. We may rely completely on the exemplary impartiality of the Commissioners not to scamp the Jewish evidence, even though tendered at this unavoidably late hour. But the same certainty hardly exists in the case of the publicists and others who are only just awaking to the consciousness that such a thing as a case for the aliens really exists. There are some fifty witnesses to be heard on this side,
MAJOR GORDON
Of the British Royal Commission on Alien Immigration
and it will be only in accordance with English ideas of fairness if the public ear is lent as readily to them as it was to those who have preceded them upon the opposite side. We have only to say in this connection that the proceedings of the Commission hitherto have been of a very painful character to the Jews of this country. They have seen a majority of their body practically put upon public trial and subjected to a searching examination unknown to other races. They have seen the faults which have been revealed—and no collection of men could present a crystal flawlessness of character—detailed in the newspapers and made the basis for a demand for immediate legislation before the other side could be heard. And they have faced the risk of a confusion between “Jew” and “alien” against which, it is true, the Commissioners have invariably guarded, but which many people may well have been unable to avoid. We cannot think that the alien has received his due at the hands of some of the witnesses ; while the frequency with which it has been sought to class the sons of aliens—many of whom have fought in the British ranks, and most of whom are almost more British than the Britisher—as foreigners has been a source of pain and regret to many Jewish subjects of the King. All the more reason exists, therefore, to request a fair hearing for the pro-alien witnesses (many of whom are not Jews at all), and we respectfully ask for them the attention of the press and of public men.
