scope than that which belonged to scholastic institution. Zeal and patience must overcome such antagonistic forces. And they are overcoming them because the Zionist movement does possess a vitalizing energy, which, when it is explained, must mold and influence the Jew.
REFORM ATTITUDES
WHAT has been done in that direction is made manifest by a series of articles before us. Dr. Felsenthal, whose article elaborated from that which first appeared in the Reform Advocate, recognized Zionism as soon as it came into the field. Few men have had the courage to say so much and say so distinctly what amounts to a recantation of some teachings with which they had been identified throughout their active careers. And Dr. Felsenthal is explicit and emphatic in showing that vagueness of theory and vagueness of purpose cannot make up a real Judaism.
Two other men have won themselves over from different standpoints toward Zionism. Dr. Max Heller says in the Baltimore Jewish Comment: “While I cannot think in other terms and hopes than those of Zionism, I am willing to let the world of Reform Judaism grow into Zionism as I have grown.” There could not have been a more signal victory for the triumph of an idea.
While Dr. Felsenthal recognizes that the Jewish mission was in a certain sense an invention of the time's spirit, Dr. Heller admits that the basic principle of this same mission, in the reform sense, is not a true one. "I for one have clung longest before I yielded myself to Zionism that we Jews in dispersion are to realize the matchless miracle of a disembodied national soul, of a race, faith, people or brotherhood, which is held together, preserved as a tremendous influence by no outward bonds of language, garb, custom (or even marriage according to the radical), but purely by a great idea. It is a splendid vision, but runs counter to every law of national psychology. We imagined it had been half realized by the Diaspora. On looking closer we discover our mistake."
The acknowledgment is courageous, and there is a lofty spirit displayed which concludes: "It is no chain of letter-reasoning
that brings us back to the old fatherland; it is the free yearning of our hearts for unhindered unfolding, for being ourselves, there where we are at home. Out of the old dreams of a monumental temple, smoking with bloody sacrifice, of a miraculous scion of David, ruling mankind in justice and peace, we extract the spiritual kernel when we strive for a state that shall be humanity's one sanctuary, for a nation that shall be the world's heaven-sent redeemer. Reform Judaism teaches us how to be Zionists in the full light of modern culture." There is no Zionist who will not say "amen" to these aspirations.
A RECONSIDERATION
THE third case is that of a man of quite different temperament, the Rev. Maurice H. Harris, of Temple Israel, New York, who, like Dr. Heller, has discussed the issue from the reform standpoint. He favors Zionism, believing that “an ideal condition might perhaps be a dispersion through all lands, tempered by a concentration in one land, each reacting on the other.” He recognizes, too, that Zionism is broad enough for all wings of Jewish faith, looking at the salutory consequences. He says: “One of the chief gains would be that of dignity. Nothing has so tended to demoralize the Jew as being singled out for odium in the nations of his pilgrimage. Take a Jew from his hapless condition in Galicia, Roumania or Russia, or even from the mellahs of the East, place him in a land where the responsibility of his welfare is in his own hands and you make of him a new creature.”
Finally he accepts Zion as Zion. "I realize that a sentiment clings to Judea for the Jew no other spot on earth can awaken. Sentiments have worked wonders; Canaan's barren hills would mean more to our brethren than the fruitful slopes of California or the rich mineral slopes of the Transvaal. Some of these zealous Zionists feel that, treading once more in the foot-prints of the patriarchs . . . not as mere denizens on sufferance of a controlling power, but as their very own— land of their fathers and themselves, that the old religious inspiration would come upon them, they would would feel themselves a great people again, capable of doing great things and giving the world a great message. With
