Vol. IV.
Adar 5663
No. 3
“Israel’s Mission”
An Examination of an Often Used Sonorous Phrase
By Dr. B. FELSENTHAL
T is indeed a grand and noble idea, and I do not know of any other one which could fill a Jew’s heart so much with pride as this one can. It possesses a highly inspiring potency, it is a stimulating and elevating power within the Jewish world. . . . Of what idea do I speak? Why, of course, of “The Idea of Israel’s Mission in the World, of Israel’s Message for the World.”
But, in approaching nearer to the subject and studying it more closely, more sober-mindedly, and with a perfectly unprejudiced mind, the result will be, I am afraid, that for this sublime idea, as usually understood, we cannot discover any firm ground, upon which we might base it; nor find any prop strong enough by which we might support it. The idea, I confess, is a noble one; but it is merely an idea, lacking real substance, and resting on air.
There is not one non-Jewish thinker in the world, neither among the Philosemites nor among the anti-Semites, who will admit that the Jews, as such, have a special Jewish Message to deliver, which the world at large is not aware of already. And not one non-Jewish thinker is to be found who will agree that the world, in order to be saved—I mean, in order to get into possession of The Truth—must be converted to Judaism. Only a number of rabbis, whose honesty and whose zeal we shall not question, and a number of other Jews who swear by every word their rabbi or their favorite Jewish weekly utters, though this word be ever so clearly a mistaken one—only these men and none others raise such claims and foster such a belief.
The majority of the believers in the idea that the world must and will accept the truths of Judaism—whatever that word Judaism means with them—connect with it the postulate that, in order to deliver their message with effectiveness, the
