The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 2 · February 1903
124printed page
scan 55 of 64
124
THE MACCABÆAN.
[February, 1903.

A VOTE OF WELCOME.

Mr. Harris Vineberg moved that the convention should express pleasure at seeing as a visitor among them that evening the Rev. A. M. Ashinsky, of Pittsburg, who, when formerly a resident of Montreal, had done much toward aiding the interests of Zionism. The motion was seconded by Mr. I. S. Goldenstein.

Mr. Vineberg's motion was carried by a standing vote, and the President in tendering the vote of welcome to Rabbi Ashinsky highly lauded the good work done by that rabbi.

Rabbi Ashinsky, who was received with great applause, in acknowledging the vote spoke feelingly and most eloquently. He referred to the rabbinical saying that if after a man's death those who survived him took up his work or spoke his teachings, it was as though he yet lived, as though his lips yet moved and uttered speech. He proceeded to apply this idea to the growth of Zionism in Montreal. Then, after having strongly eulogized the work of the President of the Federation, he concluded with a most impassioned address on the ideals of Zionism which aroused the enthusiasm of the delegates to a high pitch.

PROPAGANDA.

The next business taken up was the question of providing speakers to address meetings of the various branch societies during the year. It was moved by Mr. I. Cooper, of Toronto, seconded by Mr. H. Gittelson, of Ottawa, that the Federation should arrange to have addresses on Zionism delivered by speakers of known ability to all Canadian Zionist societies at least twice a year, the expense of same to be borne by the Federation.

The President pointed out that this motion was irregular, as it involved a question touching the funds of the Federation. It would be impossible to discriminate between one town and another. The Federation funds could not be used for providing certain of the societies with advantages unless these advantages were accorded all the societies who were constituent members of the Federation, but it was evidently impossible to expend money to supply speakers to some of the far distant cities, notably those at the extreme ends of the country, as the expense would be too heavy.

Mr. A. P. Lewis, of Toronto, moved, seconded by Mr. E. Pullan, of Ottawa, that a general committee of the Federation be appointed consisting of one representative from each city, and two from Montreal, to arrange for the providing of Zionist lectures and other methods of propaganda to the different cities, each city to bear its own expense.

The President pointed out some of the difficulties which would arise through the carrying of this motion, and that it also somewhat infringed upon the prerogatives of the Executive, as clearly defined by the by-laws.

After a protracted debate Mr. Lewis withdrew his motion, and Mr. Cooper, of Toronto, agreed to change the wording of his original motion so as to bring it within proper legal limits. The changed motion of Mr. Cooper then read as follows:

“That the Federation shall supply speakers of acknowledged ability to address the Zionists of every city in Canada outside Montreal, where there is a Zionist organization, at least twice a year, it being understood that the expenses of said speakers shall be borne by the Zionists of the city benefiting therefrom. That for Montreal, as the headquarters of the Federation, the Council of the Federation arrange in whatever manner they deem advisable, it being understood that the meetings are to be organized with an entrance fee so as to clear at least the expenses. The surplus realized at all meetings of this kind must be devoted for such of the objects of Zionism as the Council or committee in charge of the meeting decides.” This motion was carried unanimously.

Moved by Mr. A. Harris, of Ottawa, seconded by Mr. A. Levine, of Ottawa, that copies of the President's address to the convention shall be printed and sent to each society. Carried.

PLACE OF NEXT CONVENTION.

Moved by Mr. H. Gittelson, of Ottawa, seconded by Mr. E. Pullam, of Ottawa, that the next Canadian convention should be held in Ottawa.

Mr. Cooper, of Toronto, strongly opposed holding a convention in Ottawa. Montreal was the most convenient place for all the delegates except those who come from extreme outlying districts.

Mr. Gittelson contended that Ottawa had become a great place for conventions, and be-