The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 2 · February 1903
110printed page
scan 41 of 64
THE MACCABÆAN.
[February, 1903.

" 'Thine eye,with every coming hour, Shall brighten, and thy form shall tower; And when thy sisters, elder born, Would brand thy name with words of scorn, Before thine eye Upon their lips the taunt shall die.'

“May we all hope that that hour may soon arrive; in fact, I look forward for that day as I would for a dear friend who is in a far-off country and whom I expect to see in the near future.”

Bertha Schwarz discusses the issue in greater detail, and we quote the following:

“ Zionism favors the return of the Jews to Palestine. For the sake of our poor persecuted brethren alone, if not for the love we bear to the land of our ancestors, which has been the scene of our most flourishing days, and where God in all His glory revealed Himself to Israel, we should return and found a republic similar to our own.

“ For the ties which bind us together as members of one race and creed are so strong that such a republic is rendered possible. It is true that many different languages are nowadays spoken by the Jews, and that might have been an obstacle, but do we not all over the world speak Hebrew? And may we not rescue it from the dead languages and make it again our national tongue as in the days before we were scattered?

“And is not there among the Jewish men of the day one who combines the qualities of a George Washington and who could stand at the helm and direct our ship of state safely into the port of national life?

“ And when our ship is safe in port we need not fear, for “ Well begun is half done,” and the rest (though at first, like all beginners, I suppose we will have our ups and downs), I feel confident will be easily managed.

“ Then, too, what is true of other people is true of the Jews. Every race has a distinct genius of its own.

“Our special genius has always been religion. And if we be surrounded by all that reminds us of our God, would not that genius be encourazed?

“ We would not worship the places and things hallowed by mention in the Bible, for we have profited by the mistakes of others, and besides, our faith in God is too well founded to allow of idolatry.

" I firmly believe that when we have at-

tained our object and become one of the nations of the earth, ready to take our place among such, they will sympathize, honor and respect us.”

The essays anti to the movement are also dominated by the religious idea, and we award the prize to

ABRAHAM ROSENBERG.

The young author, who is not quite as correct as some of the other competitors as to the purpose of the movement, submits, however, the following well-written and clearly stated argument against the movement:

“It has always been the proud boast of the Jewish people that we are God’s chosen race and as such have the duty to teach the world the rudiments of His holy law. The Jews have taught religion to the world ever since God revealed himself to Abraham, and shall this good work, which succeeded in making God-fearing men out of so many idolaters, be stopped to let this idea, for it has not generated into anything more as yet, be put into practice? Experiments are nearly always dangerous, and in order to formulate Zionism the good work which the Jews are performing would have to be stopped for an indefinite period. This may bring anarchy or worse into this world, as the Jew is an indispensable help in reformation, and once the Jew is out of the way the world would go backward, as men do not stand still—they either become good or evil in their natures. To show the evil effects that would follow a Zionistic movement take the instance of Jewish persecution in Spain. The Spanish king was a powerful monarch until the Jews were expelled from his dominions. Then his domain rapidly fell into a state of dissolution, and the fearful atrocities perpetrated on the Cubans during their rebellion tend to show the low degree of morality to which the Spaniards have sunk.”

Mr. Elken, of 3 Jefferson street, New York, who is advertising in this issue, has made special arrangements for the sale of Jewish music.

OUR ZIONIST BUTTON

$15.00 per 100, postpaid 20c. each, postpaid

Address, MACCABÆAN 320 BROADWAY