The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 2 · February 1903
95printed page
scan 26 of 64

Mendel threw in another interjection. “Yes! Yes! The leaders! We know that!”

Friedmann interposed in thunderous tones, "For the moment you must be silent, Mendel. Mr. Steineck, please continue."

“Ahem! Yes, I will continue. Mendel says the 'leaders.' I believe—ahem!—he is sarcastic, but it is true—ahem! Where was Geyer who is now inciting you? I will tell you. Your Dr. Geyer was then an anti-Zionistic rabbi. I knew him. He was then also one of our bitterest opponents and raised quite other objections. In one way he has always remained the same. Ahem! I will tell you what he was, is and will be. He is the rabbi of immediate advantage. When we Zionists set out on our journey to seek our land and our people, then Rabbi Dr. Geyer inveighed against us. He called us fools and anti-Semites.”

A young peasant about twenty-five years of age drew nearer to the tribune, and speaking in the most respectful manner, said, "Excuse me, Mr. Steineck. That is impossible. It was known that we Jews are a people and that Palestine was our promised country. It is therefore impossible that Dr. Geyer should at any time have suggested a contrary hypothesis."

“But he did so,” shouted Steineck, frothing at the mouth. “He denied our people and our land. He eliminated Zion out of the prayer book, and then he deceived the flock that listened to him and said that it meant something else. By Zion one should comprehend something other than Zion. It should be understood to mean everything except the truth. Zion was everywhere—only not in Zion.”

The audience was restless and cried, "No! No! Geyer never said it. It is impossible."

Rabbi Samuel arose, and supporting his quivering limbs on his staff, raised his hand and immediately obtained silence. "It is true," said the Rabbi, "there were such rabbis. Maybe Geyer was one of them. I do not know. For that fact I must accept Steineck's word. But there were such rabbis. There were such." And he sat down trembling.

Steineck, however, who, once he had begun, was overcome by the flow of phrases, continued: "The rabbis of immediate advantage made our lives bitter; that is what this one is still doing. At the time we began, he did not wish that we should speak of Palestine. Now he is secure in the possession of Palestine, as we all are. He is the patriot. He is the national Jew—we are the friends of the stranger, and if you listen to him for long we will be the bad Jews or we will also be strangers in the land of Palestine. Yes, that is it. He wishes to separate us from the commonality of the world. He is sowing distrust between you and us. He casts up his eyes—pious man!—and so he glances shrewdly to the immediate advantage. Formerly in the Ghetto, the rich members of the community were influential; so he spoke according to the likings of the rich. The rich were not pleased with the national Palestinian idea, so he explained Judaism in accordance with their views. Then he said the Jewish people dared not return home, because it incommoded the commercial and banking circles. Then he and those like him discovered the fable of the mission of Israel. Israel shall serve to give