The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 1 · January 1903
10printed page
scan 5 of 66
THE MACCABÆAN.
[January, 1903.

mann Kohler, than whom no more gracious and learned opponent exists, presented his views on the Zionist movement and told the members what was defective in its propaganda. You all remember the recent "Schechter Night," that feast of reason at which the genial Professor of Rabbinic Theology delivered such an appropriate and sensible address.

I think I have mentioned every Jewish club in New York that has come to have a permanent existence. We have seen that these clubs are prosperous, that in providing the means of passing lighter hours, they are accomplishing a useful work from the standpoint of social economics, and that in emphasizing the Jewish element, they are the result of natural causes. A word seriously. We have no Jewish club as such which really takes an interest in the Jewish communal life, with the possible exception of the Judæans and none which makes for the development of a Jewish self-consciousness such as the German organizations foster.

These clubs are Jewish really in their membership, rather than in their policy; and while it is rather expedient to sink the Jewish element in the complex of American cosmopolitanism, an insistence on the Jewish conditions of modern times, now and then, would be of value. The pursuit of pleasure in one continuous round makes us callous to misery and suffering, of each of which surely there is enough in the Jewish world to-day. These clubs are the means of bringing together many influential Jews, men of position and responsibility. Cannot there be provided for example a music programme of distinct Jewish value? Max Bruch's "Kol Nidre" and Halevy's "La Juive" are selections which would do more to show our Gentile neighbors that a Jewish club is proud of its inheritance than all the performances of selections from Wagner. There is something a Jewish club should stand for—it need not preach its mission in and out of season—just as the New York Catholic Club, which I mentioned at the beginning of this paper, represents its own church.

We are glad to see so many Jewish clubs in New York. We rejoice to find our co-religionists grown to affluence and prominence. With the means which they possess, let them do something for the Jewish Orient—the bourn where night eternal dwells—and not leave the responsibility for the persecuted Jews of other lands to those who alone are willing to bear the burdens!