vented him from attending. An excellent musical program was provided by an orchestra under Mr. Elias Rivkin, “Hatikvoh” having been set for a full band. Other musical numbers were provided by the children of the Zion Sabbath School, some forty-eight of whom, under Mr. D. P. Pollack, acquitted themselves most admirably. Miss Birdie Kaplan and Dr. Christopher F. Balatka played Beethoven’s Concerto in C. The chairman having addressed the audience on the general progress of the movement, called upon the Rev. Dr. Emil G. Hirsch to address the Zionists at length. Dr. Hirsch said that he had not changed from the opinions that he had uttered from the same platform last year. He expressed himself favorably to Zionism, but warned the Zionists against fanaticism. He objected to the harsh attacks the Zionists had made upon those who did not agree with them, and he urged them to be careful of petty politicians and the like. Further, he had never subscribed to the foolish saying that America is our Zion and Washington our Jerusalem. He had not composed such a philosophy of history; the theory was absurd, and if America were our Zion, we should have to invite the five million suffering Jews to come here. He urged the Jews not to speak of Anti-Semitism or to say that it was spreading in America, since the frequent repetition of such phrases might lead to the very spread of such a movement. If the Zionists should take the suffering Jews of Russia, Roumania and Galicia to Palestine and give them legal protection and free air, he said, take them. It is not to me a national, but a humanitarian or a philanthropic movement, and if it were practical they should continue in their efforts, and he was so convinced of the necessity that something should be done for our suffering brothers, that he would accept it even if it did make a nation and it did create a state. Mr. J. de Haas, who had during the preceding week, lectured before the Kadimah Gate and the Clara De Hirsch Gate of the Order Knights of Zion, called attention to an inter-
view in the Chicago Israelite in which Dr. Hirsch was made to attack the Zionist movement. He pointed out that the Zionists did not attack their opponents, but the opposition had not only abused them but had endeavored to frustrate the purposes of the movement. He knew of no petty politicians inside the movement, though he had found that every other way of Jewish life in the United States was clutched at by the petty politicians to serve his own ends. He dealt at length with the question of the practical side of the movement. He pointed out that the question of practicability should be secondary, at least to the rabbis; whoever approved an ideal should work for an ideal, and within his understanding of the problem it was not for any Jew to stand outside and advise the Zionists, but to come inside and help them. They were quite willing, and only too anxious to be advised from within, but a national movement was not to be patronized. He pointed out that it was only the Jew and only the Jewish rabbi who, with his "ifs" and "ahs," threw doubt on the patriotism of the Jew who encouraged Zionism. He finally appealed to Dr. Hirsch personally that if he felt with the Zionists to come and work with them. Dr. Hirsch replied to Mr. de Haas, denying the Chicago Israelite interview, which had taken place in Kansas City; and pointed out that he himself was continually at loggerheads with the majority of the rabbis in the United States, therefore the charges aimed at him could not be delivered against himself. By the question of practicability he meant whether Palestine could sustain the population. This ought to be cleared up. The Rev. Hirsch Masliansky delivered a masterful address in Hebrew and in Yiddish, in which he ridiculed the mission theory and the attempt to denationalize the Jews. This was followed by a lecture illustrated by stereopticon views delivered by Mr. E. W. Levin-Epstein, on the condition of the colonies and the rise of the Zionist movement. The meeting terminated at a late hour amid great enthusiasm.
The national music advertised by Magil Bros., 708 South Fifth street, Philadelphia, can be ordered through THE MACCABÆAN. Mr. Elken, of 3 Jefferson street, New York, who is advertising in this issue, has made special arrangements for the sale of national Jewish music.
OUR ZIONIST BUTTON
$15.00 per 100, postpaid 20c. each, postpaid