The Maccabaean · Vol. IV, No. 1 · January 1903
37printed page
scan 32 of 66

try, agreed to care for them so that they should not become a charge on the public funds, were deported. Commissioner Williams, who is responsible for the administration of Ellis Island, in reply, said, that mistakes would occur because the accommodation on the island was not sufficient for the proper handling of the immigrants. Congress had been asked for a grant of $500,000 for the purpose of extending the island, and as soon as the sum would be voted, he, the commissioner, would inaugurate improvement. He, moreover, promised to dismiss any official found treating an immigrant harshly. This statement did not satisfy those who clamored for the removal of Commissioner Williams and a petition was sent to Mr. F. P. Sargent, Commissioner-General of Immigration. Meanwhile another section of protestants equally desirous of safeguarding the interests of the immigrants, decided to work on more moderate lines. They formed themselves into a society called the "Hebrew Emigration Aid Society," and appointed an official to work in unison with the officer of the United Hebrew Charities, New York, already stationed on Ellis Island.

Mr. Sargent’s Statement

Although Commissioner Williams had promised to insure the just treatment of the immigrants, the authorities at Washington deemed it wise to make a public statement of the situation, and with that object in view Commissioner Williams addressed a representative gathering held in Philadelphia, under the auspices of the Jewish Chautauqua Society. In his speech the commissioner stated that the interests of the United States had to be protected, and that on no account could the authorities permit the landing of immigrants physically

unfit. They had no objection to immigrants who were penniless so long as they did not suffer from any chronic disease.

Mr. Sargent made the following additional statement on the question:

“It is the transportation companies who are responsible for this state of affairs. This is inhumanity in the broadest sense. I have seen circulars sent out by some Italian bankers in New York, in which they guarantee entrance to this country to every one coming here through their agencies. In this business the steamship companies take great chances, although it costs them but $4 a person to take back those who are refused admission.

“The immigration officers are not heartless or indifferent. There may be some mistakes made, and if there are we want to correct them. Both the President and the secretary of the treasury are desirous of correcting any evils that may exist.

“The tests of education and financial condition, while equitable and in accordance with law, must not be too rigidly enforced. There are many immigrants who do not meet the requirements of the educational test who would make better citizens and are in every way more desirable immigrants than some who do. In the same manner, the fact that an immigrant is not possessed of sufficient money ought not to debar him if he seems to be a person fit to enter the country. In these matters the discretion of the immigration officers is to be employed.

“It is my desire that every case should be treated in an absolutely fair and just manner. I try to put myself in the place of every person who comes here with the hope of establishing a home in this country. The sight of these shores, where their hopes shall be realized, fills them with joy. Then they are stopped at Ellis Island, and, if unfit, are, owing to the cupidity of heartless agencies, forced to return to their homes. We should be just in the enforcement of the laws and exercise them with every possible sympathy.

“Figures will show, however, that there is to-day a smaller percentage of deportations than there were a few years ago. I believe that the Bureau of Immigration should exercise a sort of guardianship to be thrown