The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 3 · September 1902
164printed page
scan 48 of 54

News from All Lands

"The Jewish Chronicle" (London) on "The Zionist Check"

No one can be very much surprised at the tidings frankly published in Die Welt, to the effect that Dr. Herzl, at the second time of asking, has failed in his object. As on a previous occasion, the Mission to Constantinople has been without practical result. The Sultan has not been lacking in sympathy—who could withhold sympathy from so noble a cause, or admiration for the steadfastness with which it is championed? But “fine words butter no parsnips,” and amiable sentiments will not set up a Jewish State. The Sultan, we understand, did make some offer; but how far it went and what it amounted to has not been divulged. We venture to think that Zionists as a whole, as well as the rest of the Jewish race, whose interests are willy-nilly involved in the Zionist propaganda, should be taken into the confidence of Dr. Herzl on this question. We can quite understand that a diplomatic task of great delicacy cannot be conducted coram populo, and that the Zionist leaders must be granted untrammeled power and allowed the same freedom from public interference and criticism as is willingly conceded to other diplomatists. But, after all, there are in the affairs of nations such things as blue-books and the publication of dispatches. The time comes, in the course of all negotiations among modern nations, when the results, so far as they have revealed themselves, are made known to the people on whose behalf they are undertaken.

This is the case not only with a Constitutional Monarchy like Great Britain, but with a Republic like France, and is, in fact, a recognized international practice. We have even seen in operation, more recently, what is known as the new diplomacy, when dispatches were published almost before the ink with which they were written was dry; and though we are far from altogether approving such hot haste, still we cannot but think that the opposite extreme, of withholding all but the most meager information, is even less to be admired. Of course, Dr. Herzl is the best judge of the strategic

necessities of his cause, but most other people will think that Zionism will not only not be prejudiced by a little publicity, but may, perhaps, be benefited by action which would, after all, show Dr. Herzl's followers exactly where they are, and what they may expect. The negotiations, we understand, are not entirely broken off, and it is thought that better results may be obtained by keeping on pegging away in accordance with the well-known American maxim. We confess we are not sanguine. "Keeping on pegging away" at Constantinople is not a very easy or profitable occupation. The task of Sisyphus was pleasant indolence itself compared to it. Let anyone who doubts this look around on the history of Europe during the last fifty years, with its débris of diplomatic failures, its abortive treaties and its bitter disappointments. The Porte is the great will-o'-the-wisp on the political horizon, and he who expects least from it will secure most.

Speaking at the decennial dinner of the Maccabæans in London, Colonel Goldsmid, who recently returned from the Argentine, made the following striking observations on the Zionist movement, and the present general condition of the Jews throughout the world:

“I think we may accept it as an axiom that the Jewish race must be taken as a whole; the lessons of history point out that Israel is a vicarious people. As in the case of Shecheta, unsoundness in any organ of the body renders the whole carcass Trifa, so in Israel, the evil deeds, vicious habits, etc., of any portion of Israel reflect on the whole race. As a rule, the nations judge us from our worst and not from our best specimens. The general mass of humanity is unthinking, illogical. It boots not to argue that the very vices they condemn are due to the unjust laws often even made by those who condemn, that punishment is due to those from whom the offense cometh, rather than to the victim. Dark and threatening are the clouds that hang over our race. With the exception, perhaps, of Great Britain, Italy and Holland.