from the pulpit. There can be no mistake about it; either the fulmination or the sympathetic utterance was dishonest in thought. We cannot and shall not palliate these inconsistencies. Men in the responsible position of Dr. Hirsch are not inspired to new views on grave issues, either by mass meetings or the nearness of the sad sea waves. And if they are so light-minded that they are willing to say what best suits the occasion and the audience, then it is the duty of every right thinking man to bring home to them and to the public the inconsistency and hypocrisy of their character. For light- mindedness spreads like the thistle bloom and fills the human garden with weeds. If Dr. Emil G. Hirsch may play with serious issues, why shall not a humbler Rabbi do likewise? Many copy him, the time server and the place server abound in our midst. The garden of Israel must be cleansed from thistle bloom Rabbis.
HOW POOR ARE THEY
IF we speak bluntly of the inconsistency of a Reform Rabbi in these pages, we do not shut our eyes to the weakness and spiritlessness of many Orthodox Rabbis. The representatives of orthodoxy in America have not done their duty by Zionism, thus they are not strengthening Judaism. On the question of conscience we have not a word to say. It is surpassing strange perhaps that, if Zionism was good enough from the religious standpoint for Mohilewer in Russia, for Rulf in Germany and Gaster in England, it is not good enough for America, where Rabbinism is, when all is said, not of the stern, unyielding type. Still the conscientious opponent is entitled to his view.
But here again let us be done with half-hearted Zionism. To the orthodox Rabbi Zionism stands as the reaction to Judaism; he at least then should support it firmly and seriously. An idea which can so easily be preached from the pulpit should not be left to the platform and the expense of agitation. They who teach so readily the mitzvah of giving for the law might say more than one forcible word in favor of giving for the nation. Zionism is the living force, the vital spark of Israel. We are not
building for to-day, but for to-morrow we hope and trust for all time. It is then the duty of the Zionist Rabbi to be active to show how the coming generation can be filled with Jewish zeal.
All those who are teachers and leaders might well understand Zionism in one phrase, expressing its whole attitude to modern life: How poor are those Jews who are not Jews.
A MYSTERY UNVEILED
THE Jewish Colonization Association has suffered at the hands of enterprising journals. The secrets of its balance sheet have been unveiled and all may know how it managed to spend $2,000,000 in one year. And knowing it—what then? A display of full Zeedoka boxes beggared of all ideas. We could have managed to spend $10,000,000 in the same way and it would not have cost us much worry. Besides the Tallith weavers we could have helped the Tephillin manufacturers and the spinners of T'zittith. The makers of flaxed tapers for Habalah and the cutters of willow for Hashana Rabbo—these also are deserving of help, not to mention Melamdin, Chasanim, Shamosim, Rabbonim, Maskillim, journalists who together make a very large community.
Why the J. C. A. in buying land in Galicia did not buy the wax mines of Borezlaw or the land abutting the railroad at New Sandec surprises us—but there is no limit to the possibilities of such enterprises. Perhaps even these things have been done, for the Council is so coy and shy that it has hidden the larger portion of its Palestinian expenses under the less familiar title of “Asia Minor.”
The J. C. A. does not put all its eggs in one basket. It is quite right, for such a collection of addled and cracked eggs as its collection of petty schemes would please only the eye of the collector of the quaint and unique. Let us be done with the J. C. A. A nation begging of an idealess millionaire institution is a sorry spectacle—and the Zionists have neither the humility nor the sang-froid of the Schnorrer. The J. C. A. by its perversity has made the road flint for us; we must get stouter shoes for the march.