The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
98printed page
scan 40 of 56

stances. For practical men it is enough that our adopted country, to which we owe so great a debt of gratitude, does not require us to be worse Jews in order that we may be better Englishmen. We will not conceal the fact that our ultimate aspirations are fixed on the home of our fathers, and that we believe that the genius of the Jewish race will be best developed on Jewish soil. But, for many generations to come, migration to Palestine must be a slow process, and perhaps the Holy Land can never be more than the center of Jewish life. Meanwhile our home is here, and we have to show ourselves worthy of the hospitality which we enjoy. The distinct but not divergent claims of citizenship and Jewish nationality may be exceptional, but so is the whole history of Israel.

A. Those are excellent words.

IMMIGRATION IN AMERICA

Mr. Norman: Are you aware whether it is the fact or not that the leading Jews of America have informed their correspondents here they cannot receive and distribute any more Jewish immigrants? A. I have heard of difficulties of emigration, and that they are overcrowded with Jews. As to that information I cannot say.

Q. You know in a general way, but not in so definite a way as I have put to you? A. No.

Q. In your opinion would not the stream of emigration to America have been much greater if no law had existed? A. I think this law did not alter it much. This prohibition could not change it.

Q. On what grounds do you believe that? A. It is a question of coasts and harbors. They come in. How will you prevent a man from coming in?

Q. Do you mean they are smuggled in? A. No. I do not believe that, but they always find means to come in.

Q. They evade the law? A. They do not evade the law. They fulfill the conditions of the law, but the conditions of the law are not efficacious. Certainly they comply with the law.

Major Evans-Gordon: One question on that subject. You refer to the American law, and to the Jewish community sending a great many people on to America, or trying to send people on to America from here? A. Yes; several communities try to give them the necessary means, and that is done in a quiet, official and frank and loyal way.

Q. Do the Jewish Board of Guardians and other people assist people on to America from here? Do you know that? A. I know that several parties do it.

Q. What I want to get at is this: that in sending people on to America, where the restrictive laws act, they have to be carefully selected. Do you read the reports of the Jewish Board of Guardians? A. From time to time.

Q. You will see there constant reference made to the careful selection of the people that are sent on to America? A. Yes.

Q. Therefore my point is that if those restrictive measures did not exist in America it would be much easier to send the people on? A. Certainly.

Q. And therefore the restrictive laws in America do act as a deterrent to sending people there? A. I am not at all in favor of these restrictive laws.

Q. But they do act as a deterrent inasmuch as people have to be selected? A. Yes; and I think it is rather astonishing that a country like America does so, a country which has been made by immigration. I do not need to take the example of Australia, which was a colony made not by the highest class of immigrants, if I am well instructed. See what a commonwealth it is now. A desperate immigrant is not necessarily an undesirable man. I believe young civilization is made by despairing men.

The Chairman: That is all the questions we desire to put. I am sure every member of the Commission thanks you very much for your goodness in coming here, and we fully appreciate the evidence you have given us.