The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
88printed page
scan 30 of 56

the question so painful is that all the other people have homes where they can go back to, and the Jews have not.

THE FOLLY OF REPATRIATION

Q. But that surely is somewhat discounted by the fact that some hundreds of them are sent back to these non-existing homes by the Jewish people every year? A. It was a great fault in my opinion to do that, and the penalty is already coming back, the punishment to the community for doing it. They did not reflect that one day Major Gordon would question me. I understand the inference you intend to draw out of that, and one thing, Major Gordon, or you other gentlemen, will hear and say is: If you, the Jewish community, come and do that what shall we do from our point of view?

Q. You say in another part of your evidence that these people cannot live in the places that they come from, and where are they to go? I maintain that the fact of their being sent back there and sent back to places, as is repeatedly pointed out in the Jewish reports, where persecution is non-existent and where they can live, proves that there are places where they can live because they do live there, and they are living there now. A. There are several views with regard to the conditions under which a man can live.

Q. Another point in that connection I want to point out is that I am assured (I feel sure with truth) that many of these people who go back actually apply to be sent back. A. That brings us to the question of schmorrers and the wandering of the circulating Jews from shelter to shelter.

Q. How is that compatible with what you have said, that a man asks to go back to persecution? A. Certainly; I shall not say that all these Jews are angels or gentlemen. They seek to journey if they can everywhere where there is a charity shelter and they make the trip.

Q. We will leave that point. What I want to get from you distinctly is that these people who come here, and whom we are talking of now, at all events, are your own people and in need, as you say, of an asylum somewhere, which is the chief thing, the principal consideration? A. Yes.

Q. All other considerations are secondary to that in your eyes? A. Yes.

Q. Having those feelings for your own people, do you deny us the right to consider our own people, too? A. You do not want me to answer that question.

The Chairman: Whatever the witness says, I do not think the right will be denied to us.

The Witness: It is a rhetorical question.

Major Evans-Gordon: There has been a great deal said about anti-Jewish feeling, a thing I have personally resented in the strongest way, but what I want to get from you as a great Jewish authority is, if the Jewish people are paramount to you and your ways of thinking, may not our own people be paramount to us without our being charged with anti-Jewish feeling? A. It is the same question.

Q. I understand that you are in conflict, that there is a divergence of opinion between your opinion and a certain portion, at all events, of the anglicized Jewish opinion here? A. Yes.

Q. On what points do you differ? A. They believe in assimilation.

THE BLACK CLOUD

Q. Kindly explain what you mean by your reference to “the black cloud gathering in the East”? A. Since I wrote that book the “Jewish State” is worse than it was. Since I wrote that we have had the Roumanian emigration question. I am afraid we shall have one in Galicia, and there are far more Jews there. There are about 700,000 Jews in deep misery—very deep misery—and when I read the evidence here about the housing conditions in East London, that is a paradise. They have in a small room of a few square meters four families, and in every corner there is a family.