The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
85printed page
scan 27 of 56
August, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
85

closed the door. I think it is a good thing that you in England should first try to understand the situation, and you will do so.

Q. You understand, of course, that it is not from any lack of sympathy that I am not putting questions of a different kind to you. I have been as brief as possible, turning my attention only to these very material points? A. Certainly.

PERSECUTION CAUSES IMMIGRATION

Major Evans-Gordon: With regard to persecution, I want to get clearly from you what ground there is for saying that the immigration of Jews to this country is solely or mainly due to persecution? A. Do you ask if I mean that the immigration to this country is solely due to persecution?

Q. No; but the tendency of your statement is that these are a persecuted people, and they consequently come here being driven from their own homes. What ground have you for stating that their coming here is due to persecution either solely or mainly? A. I do not think it is due solely to persecution. All these questions generally touch human questions. I think a man has a natural tendency to remain on his soil if he has a soil. There may be exceptions among some young people, adventurers and merchants discovering new parts of the world and so on; but the average person has rather a tendency to remain on his soil. I cannot say it is solely persecution, for among those coming here are adventurers and young people who like to know the world, just like your young English people go to India, China, and so on. But I think among the family fathers, the patries familii, coming here, they only come when they are in very deep depression. When a man is already at home with his family he does not like to change his place.

Q. Have you ever been within the Russian Pale? A. No; but every day I receive thirty or forty letters.

Q. What I want to get at actually is the nature of the persecution, you say that part of it, at all events, is due to persecution and part to the spirit of adventure and the desire to move onwards. I want to know what the persecution actually consists of? A. It is an economic boycott. Is that persecution? Certainly. Then they are persecuted. This question has many forms: in one place they are administrative, and in another place they are legal persecutions. You see local persecution in one town and general conditions in another, but everywhere the Jew is the scapegoat, the whipping-boy, and one day he tries no longer to be a scapegoat and he seeks other skies.

Q. Do you know whether it is a fact that the Russo-Jewish Committee or the chairman of it, Mr. N. S. Joseph, has stated that not one in ten of the applicants for relief here even alleged they were persecuted? A. You have outbreaks and persecutions which come rarely and then you have this long pressure every day. A man who does not know what it is to be a free man says, "no, I am not persecuted" because he has not got his head wounded. He understands by "persecution" something which we should find very dreadful.

Q. Do you understand that it is the economic conditions of the sixteen provinces of the Pale of Russia which constitute the persecution, or is it a consequence of by gone persecution when the Jews in Russia were concentrated in the sixteen provinces? A. I do not quite understand your question.

Q. Is it the economic condition of the Pale which exists now which you define as persecution? A. It is a permanent state of misery; and beyond that you have the fact that they cannot better their sort. They cannot go into another town to find work. They are under a constant pressure.

The Chairman: Do you trace that misery existing now to present causes, or to causes arising in the past? A. To both. The present is a consequence of the past.

Major Evans-Gordon: But the economic conditions of anywhere and so forth where there is great pressure is a form of persecution which exists anywhere where people are overcrowded? A. Yes; but added to that, that this Jew is not sure of his life for to-morrow, and if his house is burned and his windows are smashed, that is nothing. He lives in a perpetual fear of the madness of persecution.