Q. Among the moral forces which bring these immigrants here, and the material forces too, do you say that Jewish charity is a magnet which draws them here? A. I think so. May I be allowed to add that I am very thankful, from a human standpoint, for this great Jewish charity as it is exercised in London, and if I make objections they are only from a political point of view. Certainly, I do not say it is wrong to give a piece of bread to a starving man.
Q. We all appreciate these magnificent charities from that point of view; but the question has often arisen before this Commission whether they have not another very striking effect, namely, to serve as a magnet to attract the very poorest? A. Yes, you see the difficulty. The reproaches to the resident Jews would be far greater if they did not give this charity, if they left these poor people to the general charity. It is a perplexity.
ANTI-SEMITISM POSSIBLE IN ENGLAND
Q. I am not discussing the moral aspect of the charity, I am only discussing its economic effect. You speak in this statement of yours of a state of affairs in connection with this matter which will arise in this country if the immigration goes on. What state of affairs had you in your mind? A. I shall not try to make prophecies, but I think from what we see there are the same natural forces working in the grouping of men here as elsewhere; and if the number of immigrants grows, I think you will get an anti-Semitic feeling which I am happy to say does not exist in England generally. I think in general it can be stated that England is not an anti-Semitic country, but I am afraid it could become one some day. I think it is of general interest; and for that reason I ask permission to speak broadly. This character of England as a free country is not only an English question, but it is a question of universal interest.
Q. Therefore you do regard the possible growth of an anti-Semitic feeling in this country, which everybody would deeply deplore, as being one of the dangers of this unrestricted immigration, if it continues? A. I would not answer the question as to restriction or not. You say "unrestricted immigration." The restriction is a separate question. I am afraid undiverted immigration could in time create such an anti-Jewish feeling.
Q. That was my point. With regard to remedies, as you have seen, it has been suggested here, and the view is held by many people, that dissemination of the present Jewish immigrants, distributing them from the one little center in East London to different parts of the United Kingdom, would be a proper and feasible solution; that is not your opinion, is it? A. No. I remember in my legal career—I do not know if you have such a thing in England—the interdiction of changing place. I do not know how you call it in your legal language, but I think you have not such a thing at all.
The Chairman: No. Dr. Herzl: It is not an English idea; it is rather a Russian or a reactionary idea, to fix a man as to where he should live. As I understand, English feelings are against that.
The Chairman: We have no such thing. It is a police regulation, you mean? Dr. Herzl: Yes; I could not understand how Jews themselves could propose such a thing.
Mr. Norman: Dissemination, as we understand it, means simply relieving the pressure at one point by encouraging, and not by in any way forcing these people to settle in other parts. A. I think that is a very impracticable idea. I would not enter into details, but I think that the moment you see it, it is impracticable.
Q. You hold the view that that would be merely to create in time in many places the evil which at present chiefly exists in one place? A. It is a question which I think has not been seen through by those who put it forward. A man whom you encourage to settle anywhere will believe that you are obliged to maintain him. He will always come to say, “Well, you told me to stay there, and you must give me some means of earning my living there.” It is not necessary to enter into that, I think.
Q. In fact, you say you regard that solution as being a senseless one? A. Yes; if that word is not too strong for me.
