The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 2 · August 1902
81printed page
scan 23 of 56
August, 1902.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
81

IT IS A JEWISH QUESTION

At the conclusion of his statement Dr. Herzl was examined by the Commissioners as follows:

Q. You are aware, are you not, that this Commission does not regard the question of Alien Immigration into this country as only a Jewish question? A. Yes; but after having read the evidence with a certain amount of attention, I found that the Commission dealt principally with the Jewish immigration. There was very little question of the immigration of other nationalities.

immigration or other nationalities. Q. My point is that your communication would convey to any one who was not otherwise informed that this whole question is a question of Jew and Christian, whereas the Commission, I think, regards it as an economic question. I wanted to be sure that in anything you might say afterward you understood that we dealt not only with Jews, but with Italians and any class of immigrants, just as we should with Chinese if they were here. A. I see that it is principally an economic question because of the tendency to inquire about virtues. When you deal with alien immigrants you ask whether these people have virtues or vices. I understand it is not only from the moral standpoint, but principally from the economic, otherwise there would have been more speaking about certain classes of immigrants which are massed in several points of London, and whose moral standing is rather lower. I would not say anything against another group of men, but there are those whose moral standing is rather lower than that of the Jewish workingmen in the East End. The inquiring about virtues shows it is a sign that it is an economic question. A competitor who is more virtuous is more dangerous.

Q. As to whether this immigration is a good thing for us or not, you express no opinion? A. I am not an Englishman, but if I were, I should not consider industrious, sober and thrifty people undesirable immigrants. If I were an Englishman I should try to find out the right place for these forces which are coming, and strengthening, in my opinion, the power of the land. That would be my point, I could not find them undesirable if investigations proved that they are sober, thrifty and industrious.

Q. Your reply takes me rather further than I meant to go at this moment; I will pass to another point. You say that the number of Jews coming will necessarily, in your opinion, increase from immigration? A. Yes.

Q. We must expect that? A. Yes.

Q. You lay emphasis here upon the moral forces which bring these Jewish immigrants, but you do not, of course, overlook the fact that there are great material forces which bring them as well. The fact that they find it easier to get on and prosper here and make money in competition plays at least as large a part as the moral forces in bringing them over? A. An immigrant Jew is in a condition in which he is not able to foresee what will happen ten years after, when he comes to a higher social scale where he will make greater enterprises. At the moment of his immigration his only thought is not to starve. I think there is less reflection in it than you think; that is to say, it is like a natural force which drives them, and like a water stream which tries to find out the place of least resistance.

THE POOL OF BLOOD

. Q. The immigrant thinks he is less likely to starve by coming to this country? A.That brings us to the condition of foreign Jews in the pale in Eastern Europe. May I beallowed to give my opinion upon that point? You have done me the honor of calling mebecause you want to hear the truth, and to the best of my sincerity I give it. If you wantto understand this question, you must not only try to see it from the East End of Londonpoint of view, you must try to see it from the Eastern Europe point of view; and if I mayanticipate a question which will necessarily arise, I think if you see a pool of blood inyour room, you have the natural wish to clean your room. But what is the reason forthe pool of blood? The reason is that outside is a wounded man. Help the woundedman first and afterward clean your room. That is the situation.