The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 1 · July 1902
38printed page
scan 34 of 54
Facsimile · scan 34 of 54
Scan of p. 38
Text · transcribed from the scan

so far as we ought to be guided in our actionsby the views they are likely to take. Wemust be satisfied to do what to our clear conscience is right and just, and we should notfear the consequences. Our enemies, indeed,believe exactly what they wish to believe ofus, and neither explanation nor expostulationwill convince them to the contrary.

Q.—I have heard it stated that Zionism is a complete solution of the Jewish problem. Is it so?

A.—Since all Jewish troubles have a common origin, the removal of the prime cause will solve the majority of the difficulties we encounter. In a general sense, Zionism, when it succeeds, will have solved the Jewish problem.

Q.—But are there not many difficulties which owe their existence to specific local causes? Would these not remain unaffected by the movement?

A.—Specific local problems are few, and of minor importance. The various reports delivered at the five Zionist Congresses demonstrated. the common origin and character of what had previously been regarded as local problems. We have learned from these Congresses many things which make Congresses, apart from Zionism, of value in themselves.

Q.—What is the Zionist Congress, and what are its aims?

A.—There have been five annual Congresses, beginning with the year 1897. The Congress is a gathering representing Jews all over the world, who, interested in the Zionist movement, have paid the shekel (25 cents), and thus become entitled to a vote for, and be elected to, the Congress. The Congress are called primarily to discuss the ways and means of Zionism, to take cognizance of Jewish affairs, and to report on such changes as affect the Jews. The mass of opinion thus brought together has convinced the most skeptical of the identity of Jewish troubles, has given even the well-informed accurate knowledge of Jewish affairs, and, moreover, has impressed upon the most lukewarm the necessity of the Zionist movement, and the deep love of Zion which still pervades the Jewish people.

Q.—But do you deny that a Jew who is not a Zionist is not a Jew?

A.—Not at all. We draw no such distinction. We recognize the Jew by his race and

his allegiance to one or all of its obligations—his faith, his belief, are individual matters. But we do think the Jew who is not a Zionist lacks Jewish sympathy, not necessarily the capacity for commiseration, but that feeling of kinship which has ever been the keynote of every Jewish aspiration.

Q.—But is not a Jew justified in withholding from the movement if he does not wish to go to Palestine, seeing that a partial settlement of Jews as a nation, in Palestine, will affect his status wherever he may be living?

A.—Not at all e Assuming there may be any risk involved, that cannot be a justification for endeavoring to obtain personal security at the cost of continuing the present wretched condition of the vast majority of Jews. But this suggestion of risk is, in fact, fictitious. Those who will not reside in the new Jewish state will be in rather a better position than they are at present, seeing that the great weight of misery which affects them will have been largely removed, and that they will then be able, without injury to the future of Judaism, to effect the denationalization of themselves which they evidently desire.

Q.—But if you do not fear for the position of the non-Zionistic Jew in the present or the future, what guarantee have you for the security and comfort of Jews resettled in Palestine?

A.—Our efforts are directed to obtaining that security of tenure and those rights of self-government which shall safeguard the position of the resettled people; beyond that the future will be in their own hands, and the reviving of an unaggressive national ideal will bring about that ennobling form of patriotism which will bind the Jews to live under the highest form of civilization.

Q.—You do not, then, suggest that all the people will become agriculturists?

A.—No. Many will, undoubtedly, turn to agriculture, and we admit the moral advantage of bringing the people nearer to the soil as well as the opportunity for improving the physique by living a country life. We do not, however, think that the future of Palestine is robed in Arcadian simplicity, but that it should become as it can become, if not a great manufacturing, at least one of the most important trading centers of the world.

Q.—But has not your very agitation been met by a refusal on the part of the Porte to admit Jews into the country?