forms of Theism. But we still fail to see how these historic traditions can continue to have a hold on the imagination of Jews with an utter denationalization of Judaism, and altogether cannot imagine in what way they could be shared by Miss Cobbe and those of like view with herself. To our mind the chief value of such traditions and feelings is the amount of unforeseen products to which they give birth in the mind of a nation. When all is cut and dried, to use a homely expression, no new life can burst forth. Progressive Judaism is not to be seen in a mere figment of transitory reason, but in the rich life and untold stirrings of development in a historical and traditional faith like Orthodox Judaism which Miss Cobbe quietly puts aside as of no avail in the present or in the future. The failure of the faith of Emerson and Canning might have taught her that religion is something more than a few abstract tenets, but must strike home to the hearts of
men formed by their past history and conscious of common claims with those who share that history.”
Should the foregoing excite a desire for more of the Jewish Chronicle's comments on Miss Cobbe, Mr. Oliphant and Mr. Montefiore's "magazine articles," respectively, I would be pleased to furnish you with them from its "Notes of the Week," in the same number, being intimately connected with the subject.
Although a stranger to you, allow me to congratulate you on your assumption of the editorial chair of THE MACCABÆAN, for “it seems almost to prefigure the time when a magazine devoted entirely to Judaic ideas might find a wide public.”
Having contributed my mite to bring the “Return” “within the region of practical politics” when to many more than to-day it was a forlorn hope, I now subscribe myself, Yours in faith,