The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 1 · July 1902
19printed page
scan 15 of 54

Few of these follow the example of Mappu in choosing a historical background for their stories. They confine themselves to contemporaneous Jewish life with the object of laughing to scorn its time-honored traditions. For these Hebrew novelists regard themselves as arbiters on matters religious. Each one believes it to be in his power to solve the Jewish question. Bigotry and fanaticism are made the butt of their ridicule. Chassidism comes in for a large share of it. These are “novels with a purpose”—reform is the purpose in view.

A century's growth still finds Jewish fiction in evolution. The "Ghetto fiction," as introduced by Zangwill, Gordon, Cahan and others, has done at least one thing, it has placed the Jew in "the great white light" of public scrutiny. To non-Jews, and to some Jews as well, the Ghetto type is a revelation. There are two distinct opinions entertained by the non-Jew concerning the Jew. Either he expects the Jew to be little short of an angel, or he dismisses him as the incarnation of greed and commercialism. He who measures the Jew with the angels will, when confronted with the Ghetto type, find a character all but angelic. Here is a Jew who is (mirabile dictu!) a man with the "same organs and dimensions" of other men. But he who associates the name Jew with greed will be reluctant to admit his error. It is doubtful whether Zangwill, who set the standard for the Ghetto type of Jew, has elevated him in the eyes of the world. But why elevate? Is it not art to paint a picture in its true colors, marking the ungraceful as well as the graceful lines.

This rule applies very well to all but the Jew. The world is wont to view his faults through a magnifying glass. A mole becomes a mountain in their eyes; a fault in others is a crime in him. Zangwill has drawn some very faithful pictures of the Jew. He takes care to introduce the most confidential domestic details, such as “side-locks,” “four corners” or the state of the linen. Altogether, he turns out pictures as “Jewish” as any comic weekly would desire. But his treatment is masterful. He takes care, too, to emphasize the “line of craft” for which he looks, and not in vain. True, he explains that this particular line was originally drawn there by the hand of persecution, by the “unlawful laws.” The character of Quaniar in the “Model of Sorrow” is a subtle study. All of Zangwill’s characters are “studies.” The Jewish reader will forgive him Quaniar, even assuming that the type is not overdrawn, he will blame the conditions which forced the cunning, but the public is seldom sympathetic, and scarcely ever analytic. It takes a Quaniar for what he is, not for what he might have been. Gordon, on the other hand, portrays his types with glowing sympathy and appreciation. He is never ashamed of his characters, as Zangwill often seems to be. Rather he takes a certain pride in them. He is full of confidence and respect. His Jews and Jewesses never puzzle the reader, for they seem to take themselves for granted. Gordon finds all the poetry and idealism in the Jew which Zangwill would like to find. Zangwill is clever, but querulous. He is like his own creation, Esther Ansell, “beastly subtle” and pessimistic, while Gordon is interesting and appreciative.