The Maccabaean · Vol. III, No. 1 · July 1902
16printed page
scan 12 of 54

It is evident that such a training of the people's mind was not calculated to develop writers of fiction which deals with life's failures and frivolities. But, on the other hand, it would be placing the literary genius of the Jew in a wrong light to say that it confined itself to the boundaries of Talmudism. The voice of song, winged with the voice of authority, not necessarily causing a discordance in the harmony of the latter, for their poetry, like all their literature, is punctuated with solemnity and loftness of theme. Their song is not the expression of esthetic idealism, rather it is wrung from them by the intensity of suffering. They are the great bards, who, according to Byron, "are cradled into poetry by wrong." Again, their poetry is not "the record of the best and happiest minds of the happiest and best moments," as Shelley defines poetry, but rather the record of persecution, pillage and massacre. Yet is the mournful strain relieved by a note of optimism. The ethical tendency runs through all their poetic thoughts. Their aim is not primarily to amuse, but to elevate, elevate.

Were it not for the rein which they placed on their literary genius, there is no telling to what ingenious creativeness it would have developed. The Talmud gives ample evidence of the rich creative faculty inherent in the sages and savants of ancient Israel. Their wit and humor are strikingly original. No present day writer of fiction could rival them for absurdity and improbability. The Medrashic fables easily outfable Æsop. Their daring parable would eclipse the “Arabian Nights” in their absurdity. But fiction, as we understand it to-day, fiction which deals with love and life veiled in a romantic haze, which analyzes emotion and compares passion, this form of literary expression most popular with the readers is of recent development among the Jews. Nor was it until after new Jewish writers began to introduce Jewish characters into their works of fiction that Jewish authors were aroused to the literary possibility which their people’s experience offered.

Whatever it offered it was not that material which goes to the making of a Dumas, Balzac, Hugo, Scott, Thackeray or Goethe. If it is remembered to the discredit of the Jews that they failed to produce a Dumas, let it be remembered to the credit of Jewish womanhood that it failed to produce a Camille. To a great extent, the one is the making of the other. Nor was there that in the even tempered, domestic unanimity of a Jewish home life to inspire a Balzac with the creation of a character of the Mme. D'Aiglumot type. In Jewish experience there was no material for a "blood and thunder" novel. Vice and adventure, pomp and passion—elements which go toward the making of the successful novel—could not legitimately be introduced into Jewish fiction, such luxuries being beyond the pale of Jewish command. Thus, by having escaped flagrant vice and unhealthy sentiment, the Jews deprived their writers of inspiration and material. It is difficult to say who is the greater loser. Yet there was, in their own life, sufficient stir and variety to suggest "material" for a "problem novel"; in fact, their whole existence was a problem and their survival a miracle. The many tragic experiences which befell the wandering Jew should have awakened many an one to the dramatic possibilities which their history offered. There was enough of sad truth, stranger and more thrilling than fiction, for the construction of an epoch making drama. Yet, neither the bigotry of a Torquemada in benighted Spain, nor the brutality of a