Levy, Elmira, N. Y., argued in favor of The Maccabæan, being published only in English. From a sentimental point of view, he said, he would recommend its being published both in Yiddish and English, but they must look at it from the practical side.
The chair, in answer to information, informed the convention that no money had been contributed toward The Maccabæan by the Actions Committee of Vienna.
Miss Feingold, Worcester, spoke in favor of a Yiddish publication.
Mr. Stone, N. Y., argued that the immigrant must be given a chance to become a Zionist and this could only be done by having a Yiddish edition.
Mr. Waldstein, Boston, argued that it was easier to do away with the Yiddish part of The Maccabæan than the English. Whilst there were many Yiddish Newspapers which would be ever ready and willing to publish Yiddish articles on Zionism, there were no such English newspapers to properly present the question of Zionism before the American Jewish youth.
Mr. Silverman, Boston, while supporting the recommendation, argued that the Yiddish supplement should be published at least once every two months.
Miss R. L. Hurwitz, Boston, spoke in favor of the recommendation. She said in part that The Maccabæan served to make Zionist ideas more prominent among Zionists and the Je^s in general. That if it was only for the purpose of reviving the Zionist feeling among the older class of Jews, she would favor the Yiddish publication, but she could not see how to maintain her position on this point.
Mr. M. M. Friedman, Boston, argued in favor of the recommendation.
Mr. S. Saltz, N. Y., spoke in favor of a Yiddish and English publication.
Mr. J. Coppel, N. Y., spoke in favor of a Yiddish publication or that at least there should be a Yiddish supplement every two months.
The President called Mr. Morrison to the chair, and addressing the Convention in German, explained the necessity for discontinuing the present method of publishing the Maccabæan.
Mr.: G. H. Mayer, Phila., argued in favor of the recommendation. "It is simply a question of money and if you will have an auxiliary committe appointed to obtain funds for a Yiddish supplement, the Publication Committee will give you as many Yiddish supplements as the funds will warrant."
After a further discussion, pro and con., the recommendation was adopted as read.
It was moved that the Executive Committee be empowered to pay over to the Publication Committee as much money as it finds necessary to keep The Maccabæan going until the stock is issued.
It was moved that this be deferred until the report of the auditing Committee be presented.
On a rising vote, motion to defer was defeated by a vote of 23 in the affirmative and 29 in the negative.
Moved that a recount of the vote be taken as the members did not understand the question. Recount granted, and motion to defer was carried.
The Auditing Committee then presented its report. On motion it was voted that the report be accepted. (See appendix V).
Mr. Morrison moved that out of the funds of the Treasurer the sum of seven hundred dollars be placed at the disposal of the Publication Committee for the use of The Maccabæan until the stock is issued. Unanimously carried.
Mr. Morrison moved that a vote of thanks be tendered to the Treasurer and to the Auditing Committee for their arduous labors. Unanimously carried.
On motion, the following was unanimously adopted:
Any society, being delinquent in its payment of shekalim or any other assessment which the Federation may levy upon it, shall forfeit its rights to representation.
Mr. Benjamin F. Levy, Elmira, N. Y., reported for the Committee on Resolutions as follows:
The Committee on Resolutions respectfully recommends the adoption of the following:
1. Resolved ; That the Convention of the Federation of American Zionists extend their sincere thanks to the Mayor and to the Board of Aldermen of the City of Boston for the gratuitous use of this historical hall and for the welcome reception its citizens extended to the delegates of this Convention, and that a copy of this resolution be transmitted by the Secretary of this Convention to the Mayor and Board of Aldermen of this City. Unanimously adopted. 2. Resolved that the Convention extend to the Zionist Council of Greater Boston its
