burg, Pa.; Daughters of Zion, Haverhill; Dorshe Zion, Bangor, Me.; Young Daughters of Zion, Philadelphia; Rose of Zion, Philadelphia; and Dorshe Zion, Pittsburg, Pa.
Mr. Louis Lipsky, New York, moved thatthe action taken the previous day with regardto the charter on Article 7 of the report of theCommittee on Reports of Officers, be reconsidered in order to provide for those societies whichare religious corporations and also Zionistbodies. This was granted by a vote of 47 in theaffirmative and 27 in the negative.
Mr. Lipsky then moved that every member ofthe Federation of American Zionists shall be achartered member of this body, but that a committee be appointed to formulate certain requisiteregulations for religious corporations, which areZionist societies.
Dr. Joseph Lipman of Trenton, N. J., offered an amendment that pleasure, political and benevolent societies be also included together with the religious societies.
The chair ruled it to be a substitute motion and out of order.
After a heated discussion in which it was argued that the charter would deprive the societies of their liberty, Dr. Schaffer of Baltimore, in German, made a vigorous plea in behalf of order and legal methods. He said in part “We hear talk from some of the delegates of slavery, of force, and about all sorts of things; and while all these words are being used, we forget what Zionism really signifies. Let me ask you one thing: what does organization mean without law? it means anarchism, and you don’t want to have anarchy here. We impose no claims upon you. We compel no Zionist. If you think that we are looking for the dollar, you are mistaken; it is the hearts we want, not the money. We want the money so far and only so far as it is the means of obtaining our object. Friends, when you uphold the Federation, you must give money to uphold it; but you must give it with your free will. You say the Federation has not done enough; but when one of your societies has from 100, 150 to 300 members and pays for only 25, where is the Federation to get the money with which to carry on all the work you desire of it? We make rules, for rules are but law. We must have law; we must have a charter; we must have a platform upon which to stand, and we must know what our object is in order that we may succeed in our movement.”
The Chair explained that under the charter, the Central Committee would have no greater
power than it had formerly. It simply legalized their powers. The Chair further explained that in case any society should fail to comply with the regulations of the Executive Council the committee might revoke the charter and declare such society as not being a member of the Federation.
Mr. Linsky's motion was put, and was carried.
On recommendations nine and ten, Mr. Zolotkoff of Chicago moved and it was agreed that these recommendations be deferred until the whole matter of The Maccabæan be taken up for discussion.
On Recommendation eleven, Mr. Silverman of Boston said: "It would be remembered that at the last convention resolutions were adopted encouraging the formation of councils throughout the United States, that various societies might be brought in closer touch with each other. It seemed to him that this resolution should be extended to the various recognized councils in the different districts of the United States, and he moved as an amendment, "that this recommendation be extended to include such recognized councils and other Federations as may now be or hereafter be organized." The amendment was carried and the recommendation as amended was then adopted.
On recommendation twelve, Mr. Zolotkoff of Chicago made a strong plea in favor of the sixth Annual Convention being held in Chicago. He pointed out the good work such a convention would do for Western Zionism; how it would unite the Jews out West and how it would make Zionists out of those who are indifferent. He declared the Western delegates would in no way “swamp” the Eastern delegates.
Dr. B: Gordon, Philadelphia, spoke in opposition to the recommendation.
Dr. Joseph Lipman of Trenton, N. J., declared that the Western Zionists were entitled to the next convention.
Mr. I. Kahanowitz, Greensburg, Pa., moved as an amendment that the Convention be held at Pittsburg, Pa.
The Chair ruled the amendment out of order, as it was a substitute motion. The recommendation as read, was then adopted.
Mr. Shinsky then presented the report of the Share Committee. (See appendix IV).
On motion, it was voted that the report be accepted.
A motion was made to work out an itemized report as the total amount of shares sold during
