power of the Convention to act as it is proposed that it act, and the point of order therefore is not well taken."
Mr. Siegel of New York appealed from the decision of the chair. On a rising vote 41 voted in the affirmative and 43 in the negative and the appeal was not sustained.
Mr. Louis Lipsky of New York moved that the recommendation be accepted.
Mr. Margolies of Boston opposed the motion on the ground that the council had no power to elect the Secretary and that it would deprive the convention of the ri : ht of electing its officers.
The chair then explained that the question of a secretary had been an acute one for some time. “It will not be breaking any confidence,” he said, “when I say that Mr. Morrison has been desirous for some time to retire from office, and it has become plainer and plainer that we shall need a new Secretary. The question is, whom are we to select? Mr. de Haas is very strongly recommended by Dr. Herzl of the Actions Committee. The gentleman combines several very good qualities, being an excellent organizer, having organized Zionist societies throughout the centers of England; in the second place he is a trained newspaper man, who has for many years been connected with newspapers, all of which qualities you will find hard to combine in another man. The Committee however is not wedded to this one proposition. Mr. de Haas is not here before you and unless the matter is left in this form, I shall be forced to refuse a nomination as President for the coming year. I do not mean this in the nature of a threat. I merely want to show you how important it is.
Mr. Zolotkoff : “Fortunately two men on your committee on the Reports of Officers, have the pleasure of knowing Mr. de Haas personally. I met the gentleman while in Europe to attend the Zionist Congress. His articles on Jewish topics and on Zionism are inspiring. He is one of the most able writers the Jews have. In fact Mr. Israel Zangwill (applause) calls him “The prophetic young Zionist.” We cannot find another man who possesses all of his qualifications. In passing upon this resolution, I want to impress upon you that you actually pass upon the existence of The Maccabæan. The Maccabæan cannot exist unless you have a good editor, and this is no slur on the present editors. If you wish to have a Secretary and editor in one, he is the man you want. You must realize that it is worth while to go to lengths in order to obtain the services of the right man. On the secretary
the existence of the Federation depends, upon the editor the existence of The Maccabæan in a great measure depends."
Mr. Mayer of the Publication Committee also spoke at length in favor of the adoption of this recommendation.
On a motion it was voted to put the previous question.
Mr. Hurwitz of Boston moved that the vote on the previous question be reconsidered. Motion was defeated and reconsideration refused.
The recommendation was then adopted as read.
Third: Mr. Morrison moved that the recommendation be referred back to the Committee with instructions to report more definitely.
This was accepted and the same was thereafter reported upon by the Committee on resolutions.
The fourth and fifth recommendations were adopted as read without debate.
On the sixth, Mr. Siegel, New York, moved to amend by having the money sent at once. The amendment and recommendation were adopted.
On the seventh, Mr. Burns of Boston moved to substitute the words "Semi-annually" in place of the word "quarterly." The amendment and recommendation were adopted.
On the eighth, Mr. Siegel of New York rose on the point of order that this was an amendment to the constitution. The Chair ruled the point out of order.
Mr. Morrison, in answer to several questions, stated that he had the pleasure of drawing the charter and that its terms were very liberal; that it would be far from hampering societies and that a society could have more than one charter without any detriment to itself.
After a very lengthy and stormy discussion, in which New York delegates threatened that their societies would withdraw if this recommendation were adopted, the recommendation was carried by a vote of 74 in the affirmative and 48 in the negative. Meeting adjourned.
SECOND DAY.—THIRD SESSION.
The Convention was called to order by the President at 10.12 a. m.
Telegrams were received from the following: Chevra Ohavei Zion, New Bedford, Mass.; Tifereth Zion, St. Paul; Ezrath Zion, Waco, Texas; Daughters of Zion, Pittsburg Pa.; Haverhill Hussars, Haverhill, Mass.; The Maccabees, Worcester, Mass.; R. B. Raphael, Pitts-